Don’t teach children that gays are worth less
guest column

Don’t teach children that gays are worth less


By Barbara Kobritz
Special to the BDN

A few months ago I found myself with a Facebook page. There I was, chatting away with high school friends I hadn’t seen in nearly 40 years. Until then, I hadn’t maintained a connection with anyone I graduated with, which is odd considering that I was always a joiner — band, chorus, yearbook, even class president. Then graduation and nothing. It’s painful to think of the deep, lifelong friendships I might have had. But I cut those ties for a reason: I was the queer kid.

Back then I never told anyone I was gay. I never complained about the jokes. I avoided wearing green and yellow on Thursdays and focused on getting good grades. Painful though it was, I knew if I could just keep up the front until graduation, I could leave Maine to be someone different somewhere else. Back then, a lot of gay and lesbian youth did that, heading to cities like San Francisco, Boston and New York.

I have since managed to piece together information about a few others who fled. One became a nurse. One works in medical research.

One was a musical prodigy who disappeared from our lives and died young. I’ll never know for sure about him. No one wanted to talk about him after he left town. But he fit the profile of so many young gay men lost to AIDS in the 1980s.

And me, now a college librarian. Who knows how many of those who left might have stayed if they had felt welcome in our communities? Who knows what we might have contributed?

Outwardly things have changed a great deal in the decades since I went to college. Gay kids have visible role models, gay characters appear on television, and some schools even have LGBT clubs. Yet gay teens still experience abuse and bullying at school and in the community. They are more likely to be homeless, often after being disowned by their families. They are more likely to take their own lives than their straight friends.

The other day I visited an introductory criminal justice class to clear up some confusion about source citations. In the lull before class, a young woman remarked that she had just read that in India two men could be executed for holding hands in public. A male classmate gave a little fist pump, saying, “Go, India!” There you have it, folks. That young man will become a fine young cop, trooper, parole officer, and someday he will hold in his hands the life of the queer kid who was thrown away by his family and is now surviving on the street by whatever means necessary — stealing, dealing, or turning tricks.

Both are our children and both are learning, at our knee, that some people deserve to be treated differently, that jokes can be told at their expense, that they can be bullied with impunity. Right now the children of Maine are watching as a massive media campaign teaches that gay people are not entitled to equal protection under the law.

On Nov. 3 Maine will decide whether to slam shut a window of equal opportunity for gay people. Why are we fighting so hard for the right to marry? Yes, there are practical reasons, like tax returns and emergency rooms. But ultimately I believe this is about whether we will continue living in a two-caste society.

After gay marriage was overturned in California, a woman interviewed on the radio explained how painful it was to walk down the street the next day, knowing that more than half the people passing by believed she was worth less than they were. Is that the message Maine wants to send to a waiting nation?

I hope this generation of kids will be the first to walk down the street knowing that more than half of Mainers were ready to turn the tide toward full equality. And the next generation? I hope they won’t know what we’re talking about.

Barbara Kobritz graduated from Dexter Regional High School in 1972. She attended Syracuse University and is now a librarian at a community college. She is a frequent summer visitor and expects to retire in Maine.

Not registered? Click here
E-mail this
Print this
Guidelines for posting on bangordailynews.com

Bangordailynews.com is pleased to offer a forum for readers to react to our stories, discuss them and provide additional information. We are reluctant to delete comments, but do reserve that right for those who abuse our forum. For more on using this site, please see our terms of service.

The primary rule here is pretty simple: Treat others with the same respect you'd want for yourself. What does that mean specifically? Here are some guidelines (see more):

Comments
35 comments on this item

Thank you for sharing your aspirations for Maine, Barbara.

I don't live in Maine because I might possibly be able to marry my soul mate of the last 17+ years, I live in Maine because it's a very special place, one of the few places in our country where you can live your life, mind you own business, put in an honest day's work, and nothing much gets in the way of that. People get together for their community's various events, suppers, fairs, tag sales, town meetings, and elections, and support each other when the occasional blizzard or crisis affects a neighbor (how many times have we put our pocket change in a jar at the register to help a neighbor in need?)

If I lose the ability to marry because fear and hostility win out in November, nothing changes about my life; it's still the place I know and love.

But if I gain the ability to marry because love and compassion take the day? Well, that would be pretty special, and would show me that Maine is even more amazing than I ever imagined.

Vote NO on 1, and make future generations of Mainers proud.

What else is there but love and compassion? Without it we are nothing.

To be great we must stand as a nation of one, with love and tolerance for all.

K & G - Married hetero couple for marriage equality and security for all families.

Voted "No" on question 1.

Nobody is teaching children anything about gays being worthless.

We are teaching our children to reject sin and immoral behaviour.

There is a big difference.

More lies and deception carried out by the "no" side.

Let's stop this nonsense, VOTE YES ON 1!!

No, Barbara, we should not want to teach our children in Maine that other children and their parents are somehow not as good. That would not be anything to be proud of. Hopefully in the very near future, there will be less and less young people and others who feel the need to hide part of who they are as you had to when you were in high school. Let's hope for the day when this will not be an issue and gay youth and others can just live their lives without others trying to impose their judgments on them (maybe as a way to try and assert some kind of false superiority ). Let's hope for the day when a same sex couple can marry if they so choose and have the benefits and protections that other committed married couples have for their families.

Voted NO on 1.

CHILDREN WILL LEARN ON THEIR OWN ,THE GREAT CIRCLE OF LIFE.

Please excuse me for not getting out my violin , what a sappy , ridiculous editorial.

.

VOTE YES ON 1. Stop the left wing radical gay agenda .

Please Vote No on ONE ~ Equality is not reserved for only the mean-spirited and the dogmatic. Not in America, not in Maine !

QUOTE from YES_ON_1, "Nobody is teaching children anything about gays being worthless. We are teaching our children to reject sin and immoral behavior. There is a big difference.”

Read the headline again, it says "worth less" not “worthless.” I don’t see how keeping people from having equal rights is valuing gays and lesbians the same. It’s taxing us more while giving us fewer state benefits. My husband and I are currently worth less in Maine, literally, having lower net worth than a straight couple with the same income. This is even more of a problem for gay couples who are raising children.

Condemning gays’ and lesbians' behavior as sinful or immoral while saying we are worthy, people deserving respect, is going to confuse kids. They are bound to have a low opinion of gays and lesbians, and this leads to bullying other kids in school. I think this is much more likely to confuse kids than a teacher saying some families are headed by two males, some by two females and some by a man and a woman.

Love, commitment and responsibility are not sins. Homosexuality is part of the human condition, part of creation -- NOT a lifestyle choice. Thank you for writing, Ms. Kobritz. "No" on 1.

EJParsons, you have got to be the most vile and inhumane poster on the BDN site. You're lack of empathy and compassion just goes to show what kind of person you are. Maine voters will see that too......I mean, c'mon.....one look at your posts and its downright atrocious.

You make me sick.

Vote NO on One.....because some of us do have hearts .......some of us do know how to love!

Someone hand me a tissue please...

1Jo 2:16 For all that is in the world, the lust of the flesh and the lust of the eyes and the boastful pride of life, is not from the Father, but is from the world.

EJParsons - your example of "if you are being teased about being __, if you are ___, then accept it and get on with life" - you left out a few things that kids get teased/bullied about. Intellectual deficits, physical disabilities, bi-racial, etc. So if a kid fits into these categories they should just accept it and get on with life. Nice way to tell the kids dong the teasing that it okay - no matter what behavior they choose to use - it doesn't matter if they are being "truthful" in their comments. So when someone (kid or adult) calls my child a "retard" or "cripple" or "baby talker" or my other child "slant eyes" or "half-breed" or "chocolate baby" well because they fit into the categories stated above, it's okay, it's "truthful" and they should just accept the derogatory terms being used to describe them. Sorry but I wasn't raised nor where my children raised to accept that kind of crap as "it's okay because it's true".

Voted NO on 1 - no law abiding citizen is worth less than another.

Jack

free2bee, do you think for a moment EJ was saying it was ok to bully??? It happens and no amount of laws is ever going to stop it. I think what EJ was implying is that we were all teased for one thing or another, show some backbone and quit your whining. The hypocrisy of it all is that you are the one here whining the most and and at the same time trying your best to legislate immorality.

Barbara, maybe you could be related to the Kobritz's' in Bangor...I don't know. I attended school with some of them, but their age would be nearly 67 (my age). However, leaving Bangor in 1964 to attend college in Boston, I came back to Bangor thereafter on occasion to visit my aging mother and for vacations only. In your article, it is very appropriate of you to write such a presentation, and put your name to it. In my opinion, public school systems ought not to "teach" anything about the gay population, Barbara, other than the fact that it SHOULD be incorporated into history, politial science or social science classes, that gays comprise as much of the working, productive and social population as any group that is accepted into these realms should be in this world we live in together.

No person should hide from gays or the fact one IS gay. You are Jewish, I'm Roman Catholic, my wife is Islamic...both you and I can accept gays into our circles and social partnerships; my wife never did nor will accept this community, based solely on her religious thought order. But...she does accept them as part of the world order. Jokes are rude pass-times some people like to present in public and show off their personal attitudes (as in this instance, towards gays). Not really acceptable manners, is it? No.

I feel in private family homes, the parents ought to discuss gay relationships and lifestyles, and completely leave it out of classroom major discussions and study curriculum, though. I'm not sending my child to attend school to learn about this. There are other subjects to be taught. But, as I said, the parents and others in the home should be well aware that gays comprise our daily interactions, and everyone straight should be aware of the facts some others are different in thought and different in perspective than some others and to accept it as it is. Thanks for the article, Barbara.

free2bee - It's sad that people choose to bully others, no matter what the reason. My point is that we have to get past our disabilities, weaknesses, choices, and whatever else we have in our lives that are causeing the teasing. If we can't accept ourselves, then we'll never amount to much of anything more than a whiner and blamer.

In another way......Life deals us a hand. Sometimes we add a card or two to the hand. Either way, we have to play the hand we have. If we fold, we lose.

That's right Santini/Cre8, keep that gay talk OUT of the classroom, can't have that.. It's important to keep them in their place isn't it, that is as far as you are concerned..

Who's going to teach children about sexuality... their friends? parents? no one? Should they be kept in the dark.. If I were a preteen, I'd want to know everything about everything so that I could be well armed in the world. I'd want to know that gays are just like me.. happy and free.. free to be who they are.. to have the same rights as others..to be respected. Is that so much to ask?

Santini: In an ideal world, all these topics would be discussed thoroughly and appropriately at home. Unfortunately, this is not the case. Anyway, young people today know that some of their classmates are gay. They (most of them) do not make a big deal out of it. This younger generation does not see people in quite the same way as many folks. There is less of this us vs. them mentality and that is a positive thing.

Of course, most people would agree that bullying, in schools and elsewhere, should not be accepted or approved of in any way. The more it can be minimized, the better for all.

Why should people who are left handed be allowed to get married? They aren't normal. Normal people are right handed. Left handed people can only get married if they use their right hand and marry another right handed person. It doesn't matter if using their right hand is uncomfortable and awkward to anyone. Being right handed is normal and using your left hand is a choice...just an attempt to be different and get attention. No one is born left handed. Their parents must have encouraged them to use their left hand instead of their right hand. People who use their left hand could have and do everything the rest of us can if they would just stop using their left hand. Why did their parents let them hang around with other people who are using their left hand? OMG, what if they teach how to be left handed in school? Then my kids will become left handed and think it's okay!

Now doesn't that sound utterly ridiculous? Why is it okay to some people to say this kind of thing about homosexuals? Just like some people are made left handed, some people are made homosexual. Everyone deserves equal rights under the law.

Vote NO on question 1

EJParsons - so I need to tell my disabled 9 year old - "Well son, you are mentally retarded, you do use crutches and sometimes a chair so you are a cripple and your speech is like that of a baby so when you get teased just pull yourself up by your boot straps, accept it because it is the truth and get over it. " Well my 16 year old, who is bi-racial has actually said "So, what's your point?" She has the intellectual ability to understand that those who are seen as different are targets and knows that those who bully use and abuse others to make themselves feel worth more. In the same sense those who do not 'fit' the names they are called are also affected:

What do you say the parents of these children?

Straight kids who have committed suicide as a direct result of anti-gay bullying:

Eric Mohat, age 17, Mentor, Ohio - 2007

Jaheem Herrera - age 11, Georgia, Apr. 2009

Carl Joseph Walker-Hoover - age 11, Massachusetts, Apr. 2009

Ryan Halligan - age 13, Vermont, Oct. 2003

BTW - my post was in relation to children and how they react to being bullied by other children - not adults.

forHim - Is that what you tell your children - show some backbone and quit whining? Tell me please what it is that I'm whining "the most" about -treating others the way you wish to be treated - showing decency and respect for those who are different? Renouncing intimidation by words and actions?

Jack

God's love like a mighty ocean-times of struggle makes us strong aome would stop a cause in motion-BUT not by much and not for long. When the tyrants bring their dark ways,fear and hatred hush our song.

Through the tears we might hear God say:"It's not by much ,and not for long!

We can live in hope each new day,in God's love we all belong! we'll discover when the world strays'its not bymuch and not for long!!

" This is From Not by much and not for long by Paul Svenson

Voting no because that is what my GOD has told me is the right thing to do.

What is this need to link phediphiles and homosexuality? not all pedophiles are male, not all pedophiles abuse boys boys, most pedophiles id their sexuality as that of hetersexual. Like wise not all homosexuals where sexuly abused has children. Further more its not the sexual act in its self, it more about the power, the control pedophiles have over their victims. to degrade them, to make them feel worthless to make them feel 2nd class. That the thrill the want, the need most pedophile enjoy. Last time I researched this ... the Average pedophile is middle class, Middle aged hetersexual white male.

Voting NO on 1 as that is what my God has told me to do..

Dear yes on one Voters.. I pray to god that in the future you do not have a child, or sibling, or parant or other loved one who comes to you and says I am Gay. And should that Happen I pray to God that you accept them with love,understanding and with out judgement. I Pray that your eyes are opened and you look back and see what this vote is really about..and think about the message you sent by voting yes.

Love, honer, dignaty, RESPECT.

Voting No on 1 as thats what my God has told me is the right thing to do.

To all of those people who feel the need to " " from the Bible on this issue, Please note that I am an ordained minister. I know what the Bible say, and it is apparent that what you take from it and what I take from it are to very diffrent things. I beleive that god is love, honer, and respect. God is joy and happiness.. God is freedom, and Equality..

Religion I feel is not ment to rule or lives, mearly ment to guide us as we make our path through life. Lets face it the bible is thousands of years old, it has been written and re written many times it has been translated and made to suit mans desires and needs I am sure much has been changed, added or lost , as society has changed. it is mearly a guide for us to follow...it is not the absolute law.

Just because the the church, or preist, or minister tells you to vote this way or that, does not make it right. If your church,minister or preist told you to Jump off a bridge I am pretty sure 99% of you would not.

Voting No on 1 as that is what my God has told me is the right thing to do.

Reverend Mike

One peron wrote:

Nobody is teaching children anything about gays being worthless.

We are teaching our children to reject sin and immoral behaviour.

There is a big difference.

More lies and deception carried out by the "no" side.

Let's stop this nonsense, VOTE YES ON 1!!

I am glad to say that my parent raised two gay children in love. They taught their children about religious, giving back to the community, and most important that we need to treat other as we would want them to treat us.

You have to be TAUGHT TO HATE (South Pacific). When you teach your children about rejecting sin, do you take a minute and stress that they not bullly gay youth? Do you teach your children that they should not be afraid of all gay persons and there is no excuse for being part of a hate crime.

Lies maybe not., but how about some facts! Did you know that that: 90.2% of gay students or 9 out of 10 students hear gay used in a negative fom both teachers and classmates in a year. 44.1% (or 3 our of 10) of gay students have been physically harassed (pushed or shoved) in a school year. 22.1% of gay youth are serverl victimized, ie punched, kicked, injured with a weapon. (GLSEN)

Lets stop the nonsense! I agree let's make schools safe for all of our youth childern gay, straight, perceived as gay, and those who do not conform to gender . Being different should not be a reason for other to make slures, harass, bully or committ a hate crime. Support after school activities Gay and Straight Alliance and Bible Study.

I hope that every Mainer take a good look at their values and votes their conscience tommorow. And I hope that after the election Mainers take a moment to find ways to make all our children safe in school, end job discrimation, and have same sex parent who have choosen to marry and raise children in a loving and protective home.

Jo-Anne Fournier, raised in Lewwiston/Auburn ME

You don't have to teach a child that there's something "different" about the same sex being together, for God's sake my three year old daughter saw two guys together and asked why they were holding hands. If you teach your child to be disgusted by it, then they will be, but if they find it repulsive on their own, then what do you do? Deprogram them? My son's seventeen and has a gay uncle and you know what? If he could vote, he would vote YES as many of his classmates (per a conversation in school the other day) so don't hold your breath that the younger generation are more "open minded."

We don't need to redefine marriage for a very small amount of people who want special rights. Give an inch and take a mile, just like last time.

VOTE YES on ONE.

Reverend Mike - Which denomination ordained you?

Free2bee, I think all that EJ is saying is that encountering ignorance in others is a fact of life. Yeah, there are gonna be kids who make fun of your disabled child, and the point is theres nothing you, he, or the government can do about it.

There's nothing vile and inhumane about saying you're going to encounter people who hate you for no reason. Its a fact of life. The best you can do is prepare your kids for it.

Does it suck that people bully people about things they can't change? Yes. Does it still happen? Yes. Are you powerless to stop it? Yes.

Its unfortunate, but true.

free2bee - You should do whatever is necessary to protect your children from harm, bullying, or disrespect. But, you also have to teach them that people are cruel, and no matter how much you protect them, it is going to happen to them from time to time, unless you lock them up in a 100% controlled environment. People with disabilities can't help the way they are, but they can accept their disabilities and they can accept that some people are cruel. And you and other parents of disabled children should consider it your responsibility to teach them how to cope with the cruelty of others and how to accept and overcome their disabilities. As for being targets, we all have a target on our backs to someone out there. Just read some of these comments and you'll realize that.

I was in no way trying to be cruel in my comments. I was just being real. No offense meant.

'karenlite'...yes, keep gay education out of classrooms. To my opinion, Homosexual Education is NOT a subject that should be taught anywhere in formal educational theaters. It is bad enough to have it physically "taught" in churches, organizations, in public and private bathrooms and other places. Let this be. Would you be interested in undertaking a 6-month classroom course as a mandatory course in the chemical and physical properties of horse manure? Same thing to me.

Who will teach kids about sexuality? Read my comment...THE PARENTS, that's who...and we, as parents, who have the FIRST ORDER OF RESPONSIBILITY TO OUR CHILDREN, will not allow some unknown force or person (teacher) perform this responsibility for us. If you desire to know about homosexuality, there are plenty of options available, other than public and/or private school systems. As Cher just stated, unfortunately teaching your children about sexual relationships are not always the case...not a perfect world as we would like it to be, rather, some parents NEVER teach their kids about sex. Their prerogative. Bullying should be disciplined, as this act is another display of ignorance and being uneducated or performing for the peers. Everyone here on earth has a purpose in life, but when prejudices reign supreme, this is the over-the-top issue; not the fact that we should acknowledge "teaching" anything such as homosexuality in public educational forums ought to be the new-age school thing!

Reverend Mike, I also want to know who ordained you as a minister. You are barely literate. Your writing skills leave so much to be desired that I doubt either side would be thrilled with your support. You should refrain from voicing your opinion in a public forum until you have attained at least a 5th grade level of writing and spelling. Sorry, but it is true.

You must be logged in to post a comment. click here to log in.

Powered by: Creative Circle Advertising Solutions, Inc.