Feuding over road escalates in village

Feuding over road escalates in village


Turmoil echoes in Chesuncook
By Diana Bowley
BDN Staff
BANGOR DAILY NEWS PHOTO BY JOHN CLARKE RUSS
An aerial view of the the Surprenant family's property (bottom half of photo) in Chesuncook. According to a recent survey, the disputed road runs through the edge of the Surprenant property. Buy Photo

CHESUNCOOK, Maine — This tiny village is in turmoil, and the Piscataquis County commissioners and police aren’t sure how to restore the peace.

What started as a feud over the relocation of a portion of the Main Road in this remote community in the Unorganized Territory about 50 miles from Greenville has spilled over to all aspects of the community, including the cemetery, the gravel pit, the shoreline and the public docks.

Some residents are packing pistols while others have resorted to tape recording conversations with one another.

“It’s just ridiculous the stuff that’s going on up there,” Piscataquis County Sheriff John Goggin told commissioners Tuesday.

Commissioner Eric Ward agreed. “It’s just like the Gaza Strip,” he said.

To help calm the neighborhood, the county commissioners have relocated a portion of Main Road, ending a lawsuit filed by one resident. They also have riprapped some of the shoreline to prevent erosion and made cemetery improvements, but the feuding among neighbors hasn’t stopped.

Two weeks ago, a group from the local camp owners association spent a weekend filling in potholes in the road to the village and making ditches, according to Goggin. Two days later they discovered that someone with heavy equipment had removed the gravel from the potholes and replaced it with large rocks and dead branches, he said. The ditches also were destroyed and were replaced with tree limbs and logs.

“It’s a village in turmoil,” Goggin said Tuesday. “They have fought about everything that could be fought about.”

Goggin said state police, the Maine Warden Service and his department all have made efforts to bring peace to the remote community, without success.

“You can’t get these people to sit down and talk. They’ve done that before, and it didn’t work,” Goggin said. His department has received e-mails from angry residents in the area who have accused law enforcement of not doing enough, he said. Toward that end, Goggin said enforcement will be stepped up and extra patrols will be made to the region.

“I’m beside myself as to what to do next up there,” Goggin said. “I don’t think it would behoove me to try to put somebody up there hiding in the woods on an 8-mile road trying to find somebody sticking sticks in a pothole in the middle of the night. I’m at my wit’s end. I don’t know what to do with those people. There’s some awful agitators up there.”

dianabdn@myfairpoint.net

876-4579

Not registered? Click here
E-mail this
Print this
Guidelines for posting on bangordailynews.com

Bangordailynews.com is pleased to offer a forum for readers to react to our stories, discuss them and provide additional information. We are reluctant to delete comments, but do reserve that right for those who abuse our forum. For more on using this site, please see our terms of service.

The primary rule here is pretty simple: Treat others with the same respect you'd want for yourself. What does that mean specifically? Here are some guidelines (see more):

Comments
15 comments on this item

Let them kill each other off ! I'll bet there's a flatlander up there !

If the sheriff and county commissioners don't know what to do they should be replaced. Obviously they need an overt and sustained police presence. Get the professionals and call in the Maine State Police.

This is what happens when there is allowed development in the remote areas of the unorganized townships without proper planning for more services for residents. The mantra has been that development such a Plum Creek's giant plan will bring down taxes. In the end taxes will rise and police and fire protection will be costly, as will garbage removal. Seems that Chesuncook Village needs its own sherriff. How much will that cost the county?

What a poorly written story. It gives no background whatsoever about what the dispute is about. Some of us in other parts of the state haven't heard this before, and would appreciate a little more in depth reporting.

Michigal this story is not new as you reference and has been going on now for about 2 to 3 years if memory serves me correct.....it started with "new" folks moving to the area and not "conforming" to the traditional ways of life of the community, (what to heck that means who knows!) I do remember a story about sailing on the lake, growing the "happy weed" and being reported, claiming personally property that had been used as common passage for generations, etc.....just go to the search function at the top of the page and type in Chesuncook and read the happenings in our little town of Deliverance......

I think an exorcism is in order here. Satans hand is at work again.

This is such a shame...this is a beautiful, peaceful place.

My husband and I had the opportunity to stay at the Lake

House last spring and it was a wonderful experience. The

owners, (The Suprenants) ( I hope that's spelled correctly),

were so gracious and inviting. We had a beautiful room with

a spectacular view of the lake, which has GREAT fishing, by

the way. I just hate to see it ruined by this turmoil. Hopefully

all can realize what they have and come to SOME sort of

COMPROMISE.

The press herald did a much better article on this: I would highly reccomend reading the below story if you like all the juicy details.

http://pressherald.mainetoday.com/news/nemitz/060903nemitz.shtml

Whoa - Just realized the link i just posted was from 2006 - This really has been going on for awhile!!!

daniel662 thanks for the link....I thought that this feud had been going of for a few years.....2006 story here is good and jogs my memory even more....I had forgotten about the absurd hottub and the 5 buffalo!! Crazy.....

@Daniel662 Thank you for that link. I didn't start reading the BDN online until the Portland Press Herald switched owners (actually a bit before then) so had no idea about all this stuff. That's why a little background to the story (without assuming that everyone's been reading it for the past 3 years) would have been good. With that said, Buffalo???? LOL!

You know, I'm from away, but am just a poor working woman, not someone that buys their "dream home" and tries to make it like the place they left. Although buffalo??? (I'm still chuckling about that!). The ones from away (always wealthy it seems) that move here and have problems all appear to think the same. There are no rules here, let's build our cabins within the setback, let's cut down the trees so we have a view of the water, and so forth, without bothering to go through proper channels.

Nice people or not, these Surprenants seem to want things their way. No matter how they get them. No wonder there is trouble. :D

Yeah, I think when people come in, start developing the daylights out of a property to the point that a right of way must be moved to slam in another cottage, they've just turned a little bit of Maine into New Jersey or Long Island or where ever they were escaping from.

They are home schooling their kids and I wonder if contact with locals is allowed, I bet not....is the view of Katahdin worth all of this fuss?

Thanks for the link with the background, daniel662. I didn't know what the hell this (BDN) story was about after reading it.

A poorly detailed article, another by the same author from last year more clearly describes the situation in the village:

http://www.bangordailynews.com/detail/50274.html

I have been passing through Chesuncook for many years on fishing trips, and have watched the change over time. I came to know the Surprenants after being stranded in a rainstorm, and the family provided me a warm and welcoming place to stay. While they may be "from away," Davids family has been visiting the village since the 1920's, much longer then the troublemakers in residence. He moved his family there to provide them with a better way of life and a better upbringing. They renovated and preserved a historic landmark. They brought in an attraction, the buffalo, which actually provided business for the local store when visitors passes through. Surely this fued needs to end, I don't think a family with young children need to be photographed and threatened with machetes... God bless this family for sticking to their well-earned rights.

.

Looks like it's not just the lobstermen who act crazy!

.

Isolation does that to individuals and I suspect to communities, too.

You must be logged in to post a comment. click here to log in.

Powered by: Creative Circle Advertising Solutions, Inc.