Cadillac tower proposal scrapped
Parks

Cadillac tower proposal scrapped


By Bill Trotter
BDN Staff

ACADIA NATIONAL PARK, Maine — After having considered the top of the tallest mountain in Maine’s only national park as the location for a new 80-foot-tall communications tower, a federal agency has changed its mind.

U.S. Customs and Border Protection, part of Department of Homeland Security, set its sights on Cadillac Mountain as a potential tower site earlier this year. Officials with Acadia said they found out about CBP’s interest from the Penobscot Nation and that they did not favor erecting any more radio towers on top of the mountain, which is one of the more popular sites in the park. Cadillac Mountain, which is more than 1,500 feet tall, looms over the ocean and is the only mountain in the park with a public, paved road to the summit.

Park officials said this week they recently received a letter from Barry Bracken, Houlton project manager for Customs and Border Protection, that indicated the security agency changed its mind after talking to Acadia officials and others on Mount Desert Island.

“In the course of these discussions it became apparent that both the National Park Service and the local community are opposed to additional … improvements on Cadillac Mountain,” the undated letter indicated. “As such, CBP has removed development of this site from our [improved communications] deployment strategy.”

The proposal from CBP was similar to a proposal the park received in 2007 from the Coast Guard. In that proposal, the Coast Guard indicated it wanted to erect a tower between 80 and 100 feet tall on top of Cadillac for another new communications system.

After Acadia officials objected to that proposal, the Coast Guard instead decided to erect new towers in Harrington and on Swan’s Island.

There already are two communications towers on top of Cadillac Mountain. One is a 60-foot tower with an antenna that sticks up another 10 feet, which is used by federal agencies and the Island Explorer bus system. The second is 40 feet tall, which is approximately the same height as the surrounding trees, and is used by state and local agencies.

In a letter sent in October to CBP officials, Acadia Superintendent Sheridan Steele indicated that by building a higher tower on Cadillac, the CBP project would have an adverse effect on visitor enjoyment, historic resources, and traditional American Indian activities at the summit. It also could interfere with migratory birds and negatively affect other park resources and values, Steele wrote.

On Friday, Steele reiterated the park’s position on communications towers on Cadillac by saying that the park’s eventual goal is to remove or reduce the visual impact of the existing towers at the mountain’s summit. It certainly is opposed to adding to that visual impact by increasing the number or height of towers that are there, he said.

“We do appreciate Customs and Border Protection looking at other alternatives,” the park superintendent said. “The real winners [of that decision] are the park visitors. This is another step in preserving the magnificent view up there.”

Steele said there is always another chance that another federal agency will want to erect another communications tower at the top of the mountain, but his preference would be not to have to fend off any more unwanted tower proposals. With any luck, he added, the latest proposal from CBP will be the last one.

“I hope so,” he said.

Not registered? Click here
E-mail this
Print this
Guidelines for posting on bangordailynews.com

Bangordailynews.com is pleased to offer a forum for readers to react to our stories, discuss them and provide additional information. We are reluctant to delete comments, but do reserve that right for those who abuse our forum. For more on using this site, please see our terms of service.

The primary rule here is pretty simple: Treat others with the same respect you'd want for yourself. What does that mean specifically? Here are some guidelines (see more):

Comments
11 comments on this item

and to think with all our hard earned tax dollars they always seem to come up with, someone could design an antenna that looks like one of the trees or another rock on the mountain top. Then there would be no problem.

Check these out!

http://www.waymarking.com/cat/details.aspx?f=1&guid=5df351c0-98ea-4b8c-9a84-844f67beb552

As A Mainer that visits the Mountain a couple times a year

I have to agree that there are plenty of other places to Put Towers in Maine

But I had to Gag with All the Reasons there Are

Mr Steele had to use as one of the reasons Migratory Birds

Oh Well at least there Won`t be Another Tower

So Thanks to All That Made That Happen

Put the tower up and add a few cell towers up there while your at it. Make cell service clear for all while down thier.

I have visited the park and unless you roam out behind the snack shack area the radio antenna don't cause any problems. There are all kinds of ways to hide them, flag poles, trees, etc. I have seen the tree type along the highway in Mass. Some times safety has to trump a view. I would rather have them out behind the snack shack then be on the mountian looking at a tower someplace else. seems a flag pole type on top of the mountian would look very nice...

No expletive-deleted *need* for a tall tower on top of Cadillac -- you can reach Nova Scotia and New Hampshire with a car-mounted low-power VHF radio and antenna.

Reducing the "visual impact"?

What a crock, Mr. Steele. If that were the case, you'd get rid of the snack and Chinese-made trinket outlet shop up there. Every time my family visits, the place resemles a big city bus station (choke** gag** cough**) complete with ice cream wrappers blowing around on the ground.

Do the Indians ever tire of being used as a trup card by Government bureacrats when they're not getting the shaft?

What traditional American Indian activities are being held on Cadillac? I agree with ElectraGlide, couldn't have come up with a better reason than Migratory birds? As for the view, the towers are in the middle of the summit, most people who are admiring the view are looking outwards, towards the water or inland. Not at the trees in the center.

It may be the tallest mountain in the park, but the BS is still deep up there...

You consider adding a tower To Cadallic an improvement, Mr. Bracken? From away, are ya?

The improvement would be removing the true folks 'from away', such as Woody1. These are Federal lands Woody1 and any improvement to infrastructure is a welcome improvement, especially when there is no good reason not too! It's a damn mountain that has a paved road to the top you freakish morons!!!

You must be logged in to post a comment. click here to log in.

Powered by: Creative Circle Advertising Solutions, Inc.