MMA doctors reject Question 1

MMA doctors reject Question 1


By Abigail Curtis
BDN Staff

BANGOR, Maine — Members of Maine’s medical community held a media blitz Monday with stops in Bangor and Portland to broadcast their opposition to Question 1.

That’s the initiative on the Nov. 4 ballot that would repeal a new beverage tax that aims to help pay for and expand the DirigoChoice insurance programs.

“We are certainly in very difficult economic times right now,” Dr. Stephanie Lash, president of the Maine Medical Association, said at a “No on One” press conference at the office of Neurology Associates of Eastern Maine.

“But one of the best investments we can make to keep the state strong and vibrant is, literally, to keep the state healthy,” Lash said.

The MMA is one of more than 30 organizations opposing the ballot initiative. Other opponents include AARP, the Maine People’s Alliance and the Maine AFL-CIO.

The coalition also officially debuted its first ad Monday.

Under the initiative, a new excise tax for certain beverages would be levied on distributors. According to a Maine State Chamber of Commerce analysis, the new taxes on beer, wine, soda and other beverages would raise about $17 million in the 2009 fiscal year.

The beer tax would jump from 25 cents a gallon to 54 cents, which works out to a total of 30 cents on a six-pack. The wine tax would more than double, jumping from 30 cents a gallon to 65 cents. Soda, now untaxed, would be taxed at 42 cents a gallon and simple syrup, also now untaxed, would be taxed at $4 a gallon.

Question 1 opponents said this tax would translate to the consumer as a penny more for a glass of wine, three more pennies for a bottle of beer and four pennies for a can of soda.

“The pennies we are talking about mean real, quality health care for vulnerable people in Maine,” said Juliana L’Heureux, executive director of the Maine Association of Mental Health Services.

The tax would replace the unpredictable Savings Offset Payment as a funding source for DirigoChoice, which has a roughly $50 million annual operating budget and serves 18,000 individuals and small businesses.

The savings offset is based on an annual assessment of cost savings in the health care system due to the Dirigo health reforms. In addition to the DirigoChoice program, the Dirigo reforms include regulatory and voluntary initiatives to hold down health care spending.

Even though Question 1 opponents couch the new tax as money that Maine can’t afford not to spend, those who support it have a different fiscal reckoning.

“Maine families are struggling financially with this economy with the cost of heating oil and gasoline and milk,” said Leslie Thistle, the owner of Bangor Wine & Cheese, Cafe Nouveau, and also one of the initiative’s original proponents. “This is absolutely the worst time to be asking people to pay another tax.”

Newell Augur, a Brunswick lawyer, is chairman of Fed Up With Taxes, the political action committee behind Question 1.

According to Augur, the beverage tax would amount to $40 million a year — more than double the estimate by the No on One coalition.

“Our opponents have consistently been hiding the real impact of this tax on Maine people,” Augur said.

A University of Maine economist commissioned by Fed Up With Taxes has figured that the tax would cause $40 million in lost sales and nearly 400 lost jobs.

Augur argued that DirigoChoice and other programs are simply not worth another tax.

“The real problem is that promises made to Maine people about Dirigo have not come true,” he said. “Essentially, we’re throwing good money after bad.”

Not registered? Click here
E-mail this
Print this
Guidelines for posting on bangordailynews.com

Bangordailynews.com is pleased to offer a forum for readers to react to our stories, discuss them and provide additional information. We are reluctant to delete comments, but do reserve that right for those who abuse our forum. For more on using this site, please see our terms of service.

The primary rule here is pretty simple: Treat others with the same respect you'd want for yourself. What does that mean specifically? Here are some guidelines (see more):

Comments
6 comments on this item

WELL OFCOURSE THE DOC'S REJECT THIS...IT IS $$ IN THEIR EVER INCREASING POCKETS!!! Why don't they cut their fees so people and isurance companies can afford their services.......

No surprise here. Doctors and other health care providers have a direct pecuniary interest in defeating Question 1. Don't believe their rope-a-dope and buzzwords like "best investments", "quality health care for vulnerable people", "savings offsets", and all that nonsense. When it comes to money, these health care providers are no better than any other special interest group: given a choice between the taxpayer and their own pocket books, the taxpayer always loses. Dirigo is a failed program that has never lived up to the claims of its proponents. Programs that do not work must be allowed to fail.

Poor, abused physicians - scared they won't be able to make the payments on their second yacht or third spouse.

If the taxpayers of Maine do not vote 'yes' on Question #1 , to repeal the new beverage tax, then whatever tax we get thrown at us in the future -----well, just pay it, and shut up. We will have given up our right to protest. Do not whine and whimper and moan. We are being taxed to death. If we let it happen, we deserves to lose every nickle they suck out of us.

I would like to add that quite a few of these doctors receive Medicare payments regularly from the Govt... BUT OWE BACK INCOME TAXES... SO IF THEY DON'T PAY THEIR TAXES WHY SHOULD WE GET TAXED MORE TO PAY THEM????

We are going to get taxed; bottom line, end of sentence, full stop. If not this then something else. The state has a spending problem (unless you are the recipient) and they want our money. Do you actually think that repealing this tax will make them slow their spending? We have all these programs because very few take responsibility for their actions and many want to suckle at the government teat. Some really need a leg up; I’m not saying they don’t. But a lot are just bilking the system. You actually think that all these liberal programs being abused are going to have their money dry up? Not going to happen, people, doctor costs, Dirigo healthcare, or whatever. Pessimist, ain't I?

You must be logged in to post a comment. click here to log in.

Powered by: Creative Circle Advertising Solutions, Inc.