Like a bad penny, Maine casino proposals keep bouncing back. The latest plan, promising a huge gambling palace in Oxford Hills, will face voter approval or rejection on Nov. 4.
If Maine voters authorize big-time gambling, the losses won’t be just from slot machines or the roulette wheel. The big losers will be us, the residents. We risk losing something that should never be for sale: Our integrity.
Our collective ethics in Maine are already sullied by state sponsorship of the lottery, in which poor people use their food money to buy chances with long, unfavorable odds.
Will we Mainers do anything for money? I don’t think so, but gambling raises ethical questions, and a gambling palace threatens our way of life. We can argue that people have a right to gamble, but there are limits. We try to protect residents from scams, drugs and thugs. We should also protect them from being robbed by a casino.
If gambling is such a good idea, why do its promoters call it “gaming” instead? You already know why. It’s because commercial gambling isn’t nice at all. It’s all about fleecing customers and making huge profits. To me, there is nothing wrong with a friendly poker game around the kitchen table or bingo down at the Grange or Legion hall. These are very local activities, and what little money changes hands stays local.
But big-time Las Vegas-style gambling is another story, and it’s not the story of Maine. Our state can hold its head up proudly for a long heritage of farming, fishing, lumbering, shipbuilding and other honest trades.
In recent years several projects to make some easy gambling money have been pitched by developers with the same result.
When a gambling casino was proposed in Wiscasset six years ago, residents shot it down, because this is not the kind of future we want. When the Penobscot Nation and Passamaquoddy Tribe recently proposed a gambling resort in southern Maine, voters said no. Then the Passamaquoddy Tribe tried Calais. Same result.
While some claimed this was anti-Indian prejudice, it’s more likely anti-gambling sentiment.
There is no question we have mistreated Native Americans, and they are so poor that any economic project starts to look good. But a casino would only offer menial jobs to local people, and who really believes the profits would flow to the tribes?
Maine people should aim higher than lining up to empty their pockets into slot machines, roulette wheels and other money-losers that are stacked against them.
Unfortunately, voters were bamboozled by the racino in Bangor. It’s a slot machine emporium where a limited portion of proceeds goes to horse racing. The gambling parlor is not at the racetrack, proving that the horse racing connection was a pretense.
A gambling palace in Oxford Hills won’t boost the state’s overall economy either. It will line the pockets of big Las Vegas backers, and it will alter the character of western Maine with tacky development, traffic and the sense that we have sold a piece of our soul.
As a champion of keeping gambling out of Maine, the late newspaper editor James Russell Wiggins once told state lottery officials that he would print the names of winners if they would also supply him with a list of losers he could publish.
Maine is already rich in tradition, rich in the strength of character of its communities. We are blessed with a natural environment that is our main attraction and with careful planning, a path to prosperity.
A casino is out of place here. It’s a bad gamble.
Steve Cartwright of Waldoboro is a veteran Maine journalist.
On 10/18/08 at 4:51 PM,
jsmith_08 wrote:
Repeated separate thumbs down will cause comment to be hidden
I don't understand. How is there even a question about the revenue this will create for the state of Maine, and the huge economic benefits this will bring to Oxford County?
First... I recently graduated from college. I think it's simple business that if a company owner makes money, the state makes money. Every dollar that comes in, means taxes paid out. Not just gaming taxes in this instance, but what about corporate income taxes, property taxes, etc.?
Maine law requires that gambling facilities pay taxes to the state at a rate of nearly 50%... That's a higher rate of tax than any other business pays in the state of Maine... So it is IMPOSSIBLE to "line the pockets of big Las Vegas backers" as Mr. Cartwright says, without sending cash to Augusta to fund state programs like education and higher education, environmental protection and healthcare affordability. It's impossible, and simple business. Revenue = Taxes. There's no way around it and Mr. Cartwright knows it.
And further, for being a journalist, Mr. Cartwright hasn't been keeping up with the news... He said that the casino would offer only "menial" jobs to local citizens. But in this case, he's wrong! The developer has committed to providing 97% of the jobs created by this casino to Mainers... 97%! That's all but 24 jobs! Mainers will be dealing cards, directing marketing, handling accounting, providing assistance to guests, and more!
Mr. Cartwright, like myself, has been around Maine plenty long enough to know that we can't keep turning away jobs and business. He's exactly right, Maine has a wonderful history of shipbuilding, forestry, papermaking, fishing and other industries... but unfortunately those industries are shrinking fast. The Maine lobster industry is in financial distress, the military is cancelling ship orders that might have gone to BIW, and paper mills close every month. We need something to come in and help... That's why I'm voting yes on question 2... It's about jobs, and it's about the future economic stability of our state.
Post a comment about this story
You must be logged in to post a comment.
click here to log in.
