Attorney general candidates claim experience qualifies each for nomination

Attorney general candidates claim experience qualifies each for nomination


By Mal Leary
Capitol News Service

AUGUSTA, Maine — Three state representatives are seeking a majority of Democratic lawmakers to nominate one of them as Maine’s 55th attorney general next week as the new Legislature convenes.

All three, Rep. John Brautigam, D-Falmouth, Rep. Sean Faircloth, D-Bangor, and Rep. Janet Mills, D-Farmington, claim their experience — both political and legal — qualify them to be the state’s top lawyer directing an office with about 200 jobs, most of them lawyers.

They have been waging a campaign of personal visits, letters and e-mails to the 116 Democrats that will nominate one of them as attorney general on Tuesday.

The full Legislature elects the attorney general on Wednesday, and while Republican lawmakers may nominate a candidate, Democrats have a commanding majority of the 186 lawmakers. That means the Democratic nomination all but assures election.

Brautigam tried several consumer cases while an assistant attorney general, and was the co-chair of the Legislature’s Insurance and Financial Services Committee the past two years.

“I have a variety of experiences trying cases since I graduated from law school 17 years ago,” Brautigam said. “I think I have had the range of experiences that will be needed by the attorney general with the financial crisis we are in.”

Faircloth said that over the past 20 years he has managed a nonprofit corporation, practiced law, worked as an assistant attorney general and served in legislative leadership. Those experiences, he said, have prepared him for the job.

“The job of the attorney general requires the combination of management, legal and policy skills,” Faircloth said. “I have been successful at all three.”

Mills was an assistant attorney general in the 1970s, elected district attorney in 1980 and served in that post for 14 years. She went into private practice after losing a primary contest for Congress and has served in the Legislature on both the Appropriations Committee and the Judiciary Committee since her election to the House in 2002.

“I am the best prepared for this job,” Mills said. “I have more legal experience, in prosecuting cases, in civil litigation, as a district attorney and as a legislator than both of my opponents combined.”

As Democrats, they are reluctant to criticize each other. But they all acknowledge they have their own weaknesses.

Mills said with the budget cuts that will be needed in the Attorney General’s Office, her weakness may be how long it has been since she served in the office or as a district attorney, which is funded through the attorney general’s budget.

“I don’t know the budget as well as I need to know it,” she said. “I never served in management at the [Attorney General’s Office] as I did as a district attorney. That’s a weakness I think we all share going into this budget.”

Brautigam said his weakness would be his tendency to closely manage a case or an issue, and as attorney general he would have to delegate responsibility.

“That is something I will have to learn to do,” he said, “to get to know the staff and learn to trust them with cases and when to delegate responsibility.”

Faircloth said his weakness is his taking positions on issues regardless of the political consequences of his position.

“I’m willing to take stands that harm my political career,” he said.

But Faircloth refused to say whom he would support for the post were he to run third at the joint Democratic caucus on Tuesday with a second vote between Brautigam and Mills.

“I am not comfortable answering that question,” he said. “I am having ongoing conversations with all members of the Legislature and they might take umbrage at that. I would just say they are both excellent.”

Neither Mills nor Brautigam was hesitant to answer the question. Mills said she will vote for Brautigam if he is in a runoff with Faircloth, and Brautigam said he would support Mills if she is in a runoff with Faircloth.

“My second choice is John Brautigam,” Mills said. “I respect his legal mind, his integrity and his experience.”

Unlike Mills, who will be able to vote as a representative, Brautigam and Faircloth will not. But Brautigam said if he runs third, he will endorse Mills.

“Janet has great experience representing the people of Maine as a district attorney and that is important,” he said. “I am really impressed with her experience.”

While the three are campaigning hard for the nomination, they all agree the biggest issue facing the victor will be budget cuts.

Attorney General Steven Rowe, who has remained neutral in the race, submitted an estimate to the state budget office to meet the 10 percent cut target set by Gov. John Baldacci. Rowe said it would require the loss of nine assistant district attorneys and seven assistant attorneys general.

“There is no doubt that the loss of these positions would have a serious impact upon both the Office of the Attorney General and the District Attorneys,” Rowe wrote.

The new attorney general takes office in January, just days before the governor submits his proposed state budget, which includes the proposed budget for the Attorney General’s Office.

Not registered? Click here
E-mail this
Print this
Guidelines for posting on bangordailynews.com

Bangordailynews.com is pleased to offer a forum for readers to react to our stories, discuss them and provide additional information. We are reluctant to delete comments, but do reserve that right for those who abuse our forum. For more on using this site, please see our terms of service.

The primary rule here is pretty simple: Treat others with the same respect you'd want for yourself. What does that mean specifically? Here are some guidelines (see more):

Comments
8 comments on this item

Mills would be the best option...

I agree with downbeat, Mills would be the best for the job.

However, kudos for the BDN taking the election (actually, selection) seriously and giving it the attention it deserves. It often seems that reporting for the constitutional officers' positions is an afterthought.

With three candidates splitting the Democrat vote, it's a good chance for the Republicans to cut a deal to throw their support behind an AG that will whitewash their larceny in addition to the D's.

Kudos for the BDN coverage of the race. Maine Public Radio just broke a story regarding Faircloth hyping up his credentials. You can hear it at: http://www.mpbn.net/News/MaineNews/tabid/181/ctl/ViewItem/mid/1858/ItemId/8353/Default.aspx.

I'd like to see some more specifics on Rowe's term limits issue. How is it possible for someone's term limit to expire while the person who appointed you is still in office. I'd like to see some info on the precedent of this happening in the past. I'm thinking there's something constitutionally going on in the State that Stephen Rowe is either in on, or doesn't want to tarnish his hopes for the next election for Governor.

Domino, thanks for the MPR link. I was unaware, but unsurprised, at Faircloth's exaggerations and resume stretches. I question whether or not someone with such an acute thirst for office should be allowed into such a sensitive position.

I have followed Sean Faircloth's career for quite a while now,

and he has always been a notorious self-promoter. During one

of his campaigns for office, he even affected a Kennedy accent!

No question here, Mills is the way to go!

OldBangor

That MPBN story would be great if it were accurate. Read this (below) and decide if Faircloth was treated fairly. Pay special attention to the quoted story AJay Higgins wrote for the BDN back in 1994 in regard to the Deadbeat Dad law Faircloth spearheaded and rejuvinated after it died in committee. I've worked with Faircloth before on several issues and he is a good and decent man. This story was a travesty and Maine lost out because of it. Shame on MPBN for allowing such a biased, inaccurate story to air and tar the good name of a good man. Shame on others for forwarding it.

"Rep. John Brautigam and Rep. Janet Mills joined Republican Rep. Josh Tardy, Sen. Deb Plowman, and Rep. Tom Saviello in making critical statements about Sean Faircloth in the media on this, the last weekend of the Attorney General campaign – on the night before Thanksgiving.

ALL statements below from several people such as former Senate President Pray, Republican District Attorney Povich, and former Attorney General Michael Carpenter, were offered AFTER the negative statements made by Rep. Brautigam, Rep. Mills and the Republicans Wednesday.

Rep. Brautigam and Rep. Mills specifically, and publicly, criticized Sean Faircloth, claiming Sean wasn’t appointed to the Maine Commission on Legal Needs.

Former Senate President Charles Pray: “First, Let’s get this straight: I appointed Sean Faircloth to that Commission in my stead. To nitpick otherwise is a blatant attempt to distort the truth. I am surprised at these last minute plotted attacks by Republicans, seemingly a reporter, and Sean’s Democratic competitors. These last minute attacks against Sean, an honorable individual, do a disservice to Democrats and all Maine citizens. The State deserves a positive campaign. Sean has run a positive campaign in keeping with the dignity of the Office of Attorney General. To do otherwise is unacceptable. I hope the members of the Legislature will listen to Sean’s entire remarks about the Commission (which, I understand Mr. Brautigam refuses to release) -- instead of the out-of-context excerpt from Mr. Brautigam’s recording. In those remarks, Sean talks about the high ideals to which Senator Ed Muskie inspired Sean twenty years ago when Muskie chaired that Commission. Sean Faircloth takes the high road like Muskie. Sean’s competitors would do well to follow Sean’s example, and not try to win on a misrepresentation of the facts -- not for Attorney General.”

“Second, Sen. Plowman claimed Rep. Faircloth didn’t take the lead in the Deadbeat Dad law. I contacted Congressman Mike Michaud. Congressman Michaud responded specifically on this fact issue that, when, Congressman Michaud was a member of the legislature’s Appropriations Committee, Rep. Faircloth lead the charge on placing the deadbeat dad law into the budget after that measure died in Judiciary Committee. Congressman Michaud confirms that it was Sean Faircloth who presented a redrafted version of the bill, successfully advocating to Rep. Charlene Rydell and Rep. Michaud that the amendment be placed in the budget.”

A. Jay Higgins, who just did the negative story, wrote in the Bangor Daily News – himself -- on July 20, 1994: “Rep. Sean Faircloth (D-Bangor), a member of the legislature’s Judiciary Committee, was instrumental in obtaining legislative approval for the measure….President Clinton has hailed the Maine initiative as a worthy concept and plans to incorporate it as part of his national welfare reform plan.” Long before filing his story yesterday, Mr. Higgins was requested – in writing – to contact Congressman Michaud about these facts. Mr. Higgins did not do so. Mr. Higgins also could have simply checked his own story from July 20, 1994.

In Mr. Higgins’ recent negative story, Rep. Saviello attacked Sean’s ethics for speaking on the family child care provider’s bill.

Speaker Glenn Cummings: “It was perfectly appropriate for Majority Whip Faircloth to speak and vote on the family child care provider bill.” Faircloth’s wife, Aymie Walshe, organizes family child care providers. Ms. Walshe publicly advocates for this group, primarily lower-income women. Ms. Walshe got no bonus for passage of Speaker Cummings’ bill.

D.A. Evert Fowle: "I said many positive things about Sean on tape -- completely ignored in this negative story. I worked with Sean when we were drug prosecutors. I worked with Sean closely as he chaired a Commission fashioning tougher penalties for child sex abusers. We fought together against allowing career criminals out of prison earlier. Sean’s a man of integrity and courage -- as honest as the day is long. Sean does the right thing for the right reason, and fights positively for what he believes. Sean has run a consistently positive campaign. These are the qualities we need in the next Attorney General. I strongly support Sean Faircloth."

Former Attorney General Michael Carpenter: “Josh Tardy doesn’t think Sean Faircloth has the qualifications to serve as Maine’s top law enforcement officer. Well, I sure do. As a former Attorney General, I say, not only is Sean qualified, Sean has proven he’s particularly well qualified because Sean has – absolutely -- run the most positive campaign of all those running. All this negative campaigning against Sean and his high road campaign has made me more certain than ever that Sean Faircloth is the right person for the job.”

Republican D.A. Michael Povich: “One of the most important functions of the Attorney General is setting the right tone. An Attorney General must balance the needs of society: incarcerating those who are dangerous, helping those who need substance abuse and mental health treatment. That requires a strong relationship with Maine's prosecutors, policy-makers, and other stakeholders. I’ve known Sean twenty years. I saw his work toughening Maine's laws related to sexual abuse of young children. Sean, as Maine's Attorney General, will have the ability, temperament – and positive approach -- to bring diverse groups together to achieve justice.”

Rep. Brautigam and Rep. Mills have failed to renounce the possibility of running against Sean if he becomes our Democratic nominee. Sean Faircloth, under high pressure, has -- uniquely -- remained positive. Stand up for Sean. This is not the Maine way."

Now call AJay Higgins and ask him who his source was.

You must be logged in to post a comment. click here to log in.

Powered by: Creative Circle Advertising Solutions, Inc.