Legislators target MPA’s proposals for cost cutting

Legislators target MPA’s proposals for cost cutting


By Ernie Clark
BDN Staff

Reaction to Maine Principals’ Association cost-cutting proposals to trim high school sports schedules around the state has reached the halls of Augusta.

At least two bills have been submitted to the state Legislature that seek to address the MPA’s jurisdiction over interscholastic athletics throughout Maine.

An ad hoc committee of the MPA last month recommended several changes in reaction to recent reductions and anticipated further cuts in state subsidy for education to school systems throughout the state.

Those recommendations include cutting regular-season varsity schedules by two countable games in sports where the present number of games is 12 or more and by one game in sports where the present number is 10 or fewer; limiting teams to two noncountable dates including scrimmages, exhibition games and preseason or holiday tournaments; reducing the percentage of teams eligible for postseason play in Heal point sports from two-thirds to 50 percent, with the MPA’s Basketball Committee then urged to move preliminary-round games in that sport to tournament sites in Bangor, Augusta or Portland; cutting the sports seasons for swimming and ice hockey by one week; withdrawing Maine from New England competitions; and freezing game officials’ pay and travel fees for two years.

Those proposals are scheduled to be voted upon by the MPA’s Interscholastic Management Committee on Jan. 26. If approved, the 50 percent rule and countable-game proposals would become MPA policy this spring, with the rest of the recommendations to take effect at the start of the 2009-10 school year.

House Republican leader Josh Tardy of Newport, who has submitted one of the bills, said he found it ironic that the MPA is among organizations that don’t like proposed school consolidation efforts because of the loss of local control, yet the MPA wants to take a “one-size-fits-all approach” to athletics from Kittery to Fort Kent.

Tardy’s legislation targets three of the ad hoc committee’s recommendations, including the MPA’s ability to limit the number of noncountable games, which he considers “a local issue.”

If the 50 percent recommendation is approved and the preliminary-round basketball games are moved from higher-seeded schools to a tournament site, Tardy’s legislation would seek to have those gate receipts shared with the schools involved to make up revenues the individual schools earned under the current format.

Tardy’s bill also calls for Maine athletes to be allowed to continue to compete in New England events.

“I understand you’ve got to have a governing body to protect the integrity of high school athletics, just like you have to have the NCAA for colleges,” said Tardy, an attorney and businessman who also has experience as an assistant high school basketball coach. “But at some point you’ve got to let the communities be communi-ties when it comes to these kinds of decisions, and you’ve got to let conferences be conferences when it comes to doing what’s in the best interest of their schools.”

Rep. Kerri Prescott’s bill seeks to provide for more public input into the MPA’s decision-making process, and results from the feedback she has received in the aftermath of the Dec. 19 announcement of the ad hoc committee’s proposals.

“There’s really no protocol in place for the public to be heard,” she said.

A former track coach at Mount Ararat of Topsham and the parent of three athletes who participate in track — including a son now on the track team at Dartmouth College and a daughter at Mount Ararat who competed in the 2008 New Englands — Prescott sees the New England events as beneficial to the student-athletes in-volved, including the chance to participate in the highest level of competition..

“I know a number of kids who have been recruited from that [track] meet,” she added.

Prescott also stressed that while schools may routinely pay the $15 per athlete entry fee for an athlete to compete in the New England championships, lodging and transportation for those athletes typically are paid by parents or the student-athletes themselves.

Prescott also expressed opposition to limiting the number of countable and noncountable games, citing the economic loss in ticket and concessions sales.

“Sports boosters groups are a very involved party in this, and to have shorter seasons takes away from their money makers, the home football games and home soccer games,” Prescott said. “And to take away the ability to host the New England track meet is a big economic loss to that community.”

Maine hosted the 2008 New England outdoor track and field championships last June at Thornton Academy in Saco, and is scheduled to host the 2009 New England swimming and diving championships at Bates College in Lewiston on Feb. 28.

“They may have had good intentions,,” said Prescott of the MPA, “but there are several unintended consequences that I don’t think were very well thought out.”

Prescott said the legislation will be referred to the proper committee for further consideration.

eclark@bangordailynews.net

990-8045

Not registered? Click here
E-mail this
Print this
Guidelines for posting on bangordailynews.com

Bangordailynews.com is pleased to offer a forum for readers to react to our stories, discuss them and provide additional information. We are reluctant to delete comments, but do reserve that right for those who abuse our forum. For more on using this site, please see our terms of service.

The primary rule here is pretty simple: Treat others with the same respect you'd want for yourself. What does that mean specifically? Here are some guidelines (see more):

Comments
5 comments on this item

Good for you Rep. Tardy for finally articulating the frustration many have felt regarding the MPA and their "governance". I have asked this before - who granted them jurisdiction over inter-scholastic athletics? The Legislature? Or were they self appointed. Vintage MPA move - the prelim games go to the venue where the MPA will make the money. How much taxpayer money supports the MPA organization?

The MAINE PRINCIPALS' ASSOCIATION should focus on supporting, building capacity and offering MEANINGFUL professional development to PRINCIPALS....now there is a thought. In essence, they have "gotten too big for their britches". Their opposition to consolidation had nothing to do with quality education nor the impact on the building principals - it was about CONTROL.

The tournament is the MPA cash cow - and they are all about MONEY - not student athletes.

First, let's reveal that Rep. Tardy's brother is the AD at Nokomis. I guess what all this means is instead of an MPA Invitational Tournament based on the Heal System, we should return to the previous method of selecting tournament teams - a few chosen AD's in a back room making the selections. Rep. Tardy's brother would be the chairman-for-life, of course. Or perhaps the officers of the various booster clubs at chosen high schools. That would be novel. And they could keep the money.

The tournaments are being called the MPA's cash cow, a cash cow that supports every other tournament except cheering, the only other tournament in the state besides basketball that makes money. So we could lose not just the one New England track meet but state meets as well. That would put a dent in your attempt to get your child a scholarship. And speaking of cash cows, what are the pre-season and holiday tournaments. Are they not cash cows. And do they count for nothing at all - except, perhaps, another recruiting tool to get your child a scholarship.

If the costs are minimal, I do not think Maine should withdraw from New England Championships.

Just because Maine did not compete in New England Championships when I was in high school or I did not get the chance to until college, I do not believe in taking that opportunity away from another generation.

Most sporting events charge people to watch the event, and make money off of concessions. I would also imagine when Maine hosts a New England Championship event, it would bring people from out of state to spend money, and possibly vacation a little while they are here. I would think that would be good for the state of Maine.

Please weigh the costs before making decisions.

I have offered to officiate unconcerned of pay. Need an official? As long as I am free, I will do it.

I do not think that high schools should HAVE to move their championship games. I would think that would cost both competing schools more money to get to the location than to save money by having only one worry about transportation costs.

Also, I think if a community can raise additional money they should be able to spend the money on counted or uncounted games, housing, lodging, transportation or spend their money on whatever they deem appropriate. I thought this is supposed to be the land of opportunity, not the land of usurpations and suppression according to our Declaration of Independence.

Hey Woody1 - so its OK to have a few principals in the backroom making decisions? Regarding your comment on pre-season and holiday tournaments...all that money goes directly to the LOCAL program - probably to buy new uniforms or for the end of the year banquet or travel - not toward supporting the administrative and overhead costs of an organization that needs to do a gut check. Perhaps if the locals pledged to send a portion of their proceeds to the MPA, this issue would be moot!

The MPA needs to focus on the principalship. It is time for high school athletics to be a separate entity. (But according to you, the ATHLETIC DIRECTORS, are too shady to do that...??)

Interesting how being uninformed leads to vitriol. The MPA is run by VOLUNTEER principals who get nothing from the "cash cow" of tournaments except the opportunity to fund non-income-generating experiences for kids such as the Student Council events, NHS trips, competition one-act plays, etc. Where on earth would anyone get the idea that THEY profit from their service??? Oh, those greedy prinipals who spend long days in meetings trying to provide continuity and equity for schools. But hey, abolish them (and the NCAA while you're at it) and see the chaos that ensues...

You must be logged in to post a comment. click here to log in.

Powered by: Creative Circle Advertising Solutions, Inc.