OWLS HEAD, Maine — Cassidy Keene’s life has changed dramatically in the weeks since her son’s hand was severed in an accident in Rockland.

Before, Keene drove her twin boys to summer camp where they could swim and jump around like rambunctious 5-year-olds do. She’d go to work as a nurse and then pick them up, make dinner and put them to bed quietly.

Now the boys, Noah and Patrick, can’t sleep at night, Keene said. They wet their beds and are afraid of the dark — both new developments. They act out more. Noah can’t go to summer camp and it’s unclear if he will be healed enough to go to kindergarten on time. Doctors aren’t sure if he’ll ever have the full function of his hand back, she said.

Noah’s hand was severed in late June after a jump rope he had twisted around his wrist and dangled out a car window got caught on the wheel of the vehicle. The accident severed his left hand and left him with a broken humerus.

Rockland police initially had said the rope had become caught in the wheel of a passing vehicle but that later was determined to be incorrect.

Surgeons at a Boston hospital were able to reattach his hand. They put something similar to a large nail in his small arm to heal his humerus. They put pins in his hand and grafted skin to his wrist where it wasn’t going to heal itself. Noah’s arm was put in a camouflage cast, which since has been taken off.

Now his arm is in a splint and he will enter physical therapy next week. There is no prognosis yet. Doctors are waiting for nerve regeneration, Keene, 30, of Owls Head, said. The good news is he’s feeling pain in the hand — which is also the bad news for the suffering child.

“‘It’s swollen but it looks good.’ That’s what the surgeons say. But to a 5-year-old, it looks like Frankenstein. He has a pin that sticks out and he calls it his Wolverine hand,” she said.

Watching her small child suffer has been difficult for Keene. She tries to see the bright side of things, but mornings have become hard to cope with. That’s when Keene takes off Noah’s old bandage and redresses the wound.

“He screams in terror at his own hand. It terrifies him,” she said. “I would stand on my head and tell him knock-knock jokes if I thought it would make it better.”

One thing making it difficult for Keene to stay optimistic is an impending court case. Noah’s father is suing Keene’s mother, who was driving the car the day of Noah’s accident.

Keene’s mother, Sharon Setz of Rockland, watches the boys regularly. When Keene decided to go back to school to become a nurse when the boys were 8 months old, Setz was the one who baby-sat during Keene’s school hours and while she worked cleaning houses and at Amalfi, a Rockland restaurant. And now that Noah can’t go swimming — one of his favorite activities — Setz tries to make fun indoor activities for him, such as going to the toy store while his twin brother plays at summer camp.

When Keene heard of the lawsuit she was shocked.

“It was a really unfortunate time for an absent father to re-enter their lives. Court isn’t the place our family has to be at this point,” she said.

According to Keene, the boys’ father, Anthony Pignone, left them when she was six months pregnant with the twins.

The father’s attorney refused to comment for this story. Pignone was not reachable for comment.

“Cassidy will have to be involved in the litigation. There is no way around it,” said Keene’s attorney, Sarah Irving Gilbert.

Pignone’s lawsuit claims that Setz acted negligently by allowing Noah to dangle the jump rope out the window. It also said her negligence caused emotional and psychological trauma to Patrick. The lawsuit does not specify the amount of damages being sought.

“I was shocked. Absolutely shocked,” Keene said. “My mother was broken when this happened. She’s a caring, loving grandmother. You could see it in her face at the ER [on the day of the accident]. She was broken. I just wrapped her in a hug and told her, ‘I love you and it will be OK.’ Kids will be kids. My boys will be boys. I never got angry at her ever. Twins are a handful and they need a lot of love and attention. What happened was an accident.”

The community support Keene has gotten has helped her through the tougher times, she said. Part of that were fundraisers that collected $30,000 for the family.

“This has been the hardest thing my family has ever had to go through,” she said. “When you’re at the end of your rope, strangers throw you more rope and kept me afloat. We couldn’t be more grateful.”

Keene got time off work and doesn’t have to worry about losing her job, but she hasn’t had a paycheck since late June, when the accident happened. At the same time, she has needed to take many trips to Boston and stay there while Noah has surgeries. The money the community raised allows her to help Noah without having to worry about immediately returning to work, she said.

But life will never go back to normal for her family, Keene said.

“We will have to redefine normal moving forward,” Keene said. “It’s a huge emotional impact that’s hard to get over. As a mother, part of you changes when you realize you could have lost your child.”

“I try to have faith and look at the best in the situation — kids will be kids and they will fall and learn things,” she continued. “But then something like this happened and you want to follow them around like a warden. This was an accident — it was a split-second bad decision. That’s what accident means.”

Join the Conversation

78 Comments

  1. “It was a really unfortunate time for an absent father to re-enter their lives. Court isn’t the place our family has to be at this point,” she said.

    I couldn’t agree more!  Often times the greed and sleeziness of humanity disgusts me.

    1. For the indolent good-for-nothings in the world, filing lawsuits  is typical of what they do when they see a big pay-off in their future.

      We’ve all witnessed how impoverished men or women make it in the big-time, be it sports, theater, Hollywood or business successes….and all of a sudden a long-lost absent parent surfaces. Surprise, surprise.

      They seem to be compelled by a sudden and new-found  parental affection that sprang into their hearts. If their highly successful offspring refuses to recognize the long-lost absent parents newly found affection, the good-for-nothing finds a lawyer and files a lawsuit to retaliate against the stubborness of their well-heeled and succesful offspring in  not recognize their sudden leap of understanding of parental duties.

      These human slugs are bottom of the barrel material.

  2. I’m definitely praying for Noah. I cannot believe that his absent father would stoop so low and try to sue his grandmother. If he had a heart, he’d drop all charges. Accidents happen.

    1. If he had a heart, he wouldn’t have run out on their mom when she was six months pregnant.
      I think we can all agree he has no heart.

  3. Sounds to me like the ABSENT father is trying to benefit from this horrible ACCIDENT! He is the loser for not being part of their lives from the beginning and should get nothing!

  4. Praying for Noah, and your whole family during this healing process. I HOPE this “absent” father gets NOTHING from this lawsuit!!!! How greedy!
     

    1. I keep wondering two things. 1) If the father isn’t in the boy’s life, how did he get standing to sue? and 2) What attorney took this case since it’s a long shot. To sue for negligence he has to meet several prongs, one of which is whether the event was foreseeable. How could it ever be foreseeable that a child would twist a rope around his hand and have it latch onto a steering wheel (from a former article) and that be the cause of a radical amputation? 

    2. That is soo true and since my previous comments seem to have been deleted I would also like to add that if any money is won through a lawsuit it should be put into a custodial account for the child  with an independent Gaurdian Ad Litem.

  5. I’m sure the judge will be impressed with the absent father’s lawsuit!! Good grief. get a life!!
    Prayers to the boy and his family!

  6. I can’t imagine what this mother and grandmother are going through in trying to help these young twins get through their ordeal. Being twins I think they are both suffering. What this family doesn’t need is the father filing a lawsuit. He doesn’t even know the children does he? Somewhere there is a light at the end of the tunnel. Hope it shows itself soon.

  7. The dad hasn’t been involved with them since she was six months pregnat with them. The dad doesn’t care he wants the money. This was an accident pure and simple. Just because there was a jump rope in the back seat of the care who could have seen this happening? When driving your suppose to keep your eyes on the road. You know children are going to fall and bump their heads so should all children be rquired to wear helmets because more then likely it’s going to happen. The only way you can protect children from getting hurt is to put them in a protected bubble and not let them do anything.

    1. Yeah really, with the new driver distraction law, should we not be allowed to drive with children in the vehicle?

  8.  This has been such a difficult time for this family, and these women and children are obviously incredibly strong women.  The worst times in our lives bring on the greatest growth and the most positive changes. 
     
    My son experience great misfortune and injury at a very young age.  We also suffered, and we also went on and lived our lives to the fullest.  Yes, it changed us into different people, but every day we wake up.  We are healthy, happy and have wonderful lives.  He is 42 now.  He has children of his own, and he’s a great father, a great son, and a great partner.  We are both exptremely greatful for who we have become and the wonderful lives we have lived so far.  All of it.  And we love our family. 
     
    Please remember, the boys Grandmother will always be his Grandmother, no matter what kind of accident that has happened.  Everything she does shows the love she has for these boys, and that stays with them for their entire lives.  While she is suffering from this, as everyone is, she is so strong, standing side by side with this incredible Mother, and taking on all of life’s challenges.  
     
    At the same time, the boy’s Father will always be  their father, and if they love him, they will always love him.  Think about he comments you make on a family that is struggling with so much right now.  Whatever you say about anyone in this family can cause greater harm to these children.  Support, love and understanding is what they all need right now.

    1. While that is a nice sentiment I would have a very hard time including the father unit as part of this family.  I also disagree that the children will always love their father – I guess that would depend on when their innocence about their father leaving the family wears off and they start to resent him.  I agree with some of the other posters – his lawsuit should be thrown out – I think he gave up his rights to make decisions regarding the children when he left and chose to be absent from their lives.  

      I am a grandmother and my heart goes out to both the mother and especially the grandmother.  The love a grandmother has for her grandchildren is larger than I could have ever imagined and she must torture herself and second guess everything she does for those little boys now – regardless of the fact that it was an accident.   It sounds as though they have spent a great deal of time with her as their second caregiver and she was there for them – the father wasn’t.  He has no right to torment the grandmother this way.  

      I pray for a complete and speedy recovery for the little boy physically and for all their hearts and minds  to heal, especially grandma’s

      1. I agree, with almost everything…but this man is their Father.  Always will be, and none other.  It’s up to them where that goes.  Not us.  You are right about the lawsuit, based on what I know.  I hope it does get dropped.  I’m sure it will.  You are a caring wonderful member of the community.  Thank you for your message.

        1. no, he’s not a father. Fathers are there for their children, and don’t walk out on their pregnant significant other. I know men who didn’t “father” their children, but loved them and took care of them as if they were their own. Just because one can produce children, doesn’t make them a parent. 

        2.  fa·ther 

          NOUN:
          A man who raises or nurtures a child.

          sperm donor

          The person that gets a female pregnant but
          doesn’t help her with the child in any way, shape, or form. In some
          cases they don’t acknowledge the child at all.

          This ‘man’ left Miss Keene when she was 6 months pregnant. These boys don’t know this man. According to the definitions I pulled up, he is not a father. He is a sperm donor.

  9. do you mean the sperm donor?  these boys never had a father.   the psychological term for what you are doing is called “projection.” Your comments are quite revealing.

  10. If the father has been absent on his own accord as the article suggests, he has no right to file any suit against anyone regarding his children!

    1. They are no more his children than the results of sperm banks are the children of the donors.

    2. Absent or not, he’s the legal father of these children he has the right, I’m not saying I agree with that but from a legal standpoint he  has just as much of a right as their mother to so. It is totally messed up and wrong!!

  11. You are suggesting that all those who drive with children in the car…keep their eyes on the backseat and NOT THE ROAD?  Seriously?  And to call him a dad is quite a stretch.  Sperm donor, maybe.

  12. I wonder if they would consider amputating the hand if it doesn’t heal well. I’ve had quite a few friends get in terrible accidents, their limbs were ‘saved’ but were largely useless, caused a lot of pain and were in a constant state of not-quite-healed.

    My one friend says “My choice in life was to be a cripple, or an amputee.’ He elected to have the leg removed, and has been skiing, biking, hiking, climbing ever since. Myself, I was born without a hand, and life has been pretty sweet. Noah, you can swim just fine with one hand, that’s for sure!

    Ms. Keene, you should check out Paradox Sports (paradoxsports.org) for way and stories of people who have overcome physical issues and get on just dandy. I’d be more than happy to take Noah out for a day of gimpy one handed fun!

    1. That is the best comment I have read on here today. It took the scowl right off my face and turned it into a smile. Thank you, I really needed that.

  13. But what is the point of him suing the grandmother?  It serves no purpose.  He isn’t involved in the kids’ lives, he more than likely has nothing to do with any of the medical stuff including bills, so what happens to the money if he wins?  This suit serves no purpose other than he is looking to make a buck.

  14. ACCIDENTS HAPPEN and that is one of the bigges problems with our society today.  BLAME someone needs to be able to blame and for money.  I am so sorry for what this child, his brother nad his mother and other family are going through.  But it was an ACCIDENT.

  15. So, the “loving left them father” re-enters their lives long enough to express his “concern” for Patrick, then he will be on the run again.  Sleazy lawyers take these cases!

  16. These are the same”Dads” that come skulking around when their sons and daughters get a multi million dollar pro contract.

  17. What a darling child; it’s heartbreaking to read the pain he has suffered and the pain he and his brother and real family continue to suffer. 

    The “father” seems like a real piece of crap. I wonder who he was able to convince to take this “case.” I hope they don’t get a dime and have to eat all their legal fees.

    I’m glad to see that the mother has retained counsel to help protect her and her sons. It is extremely unfortunate that during a time when the mother should be able to focus on the physical and psychological trauma suffered by poor little Noah, she has to be dragged into this circus. 

    Accidents happen; it’s not time for this waste to cash in on this child’s suffering or the grandmother’s grief. This shell of a man disgusts me.

  18. This was a tragic accident that could have happened to any one of us.  If one of the boys cannot start kindergarten in Sept.  you might consider holding both of the boys out so they can stay in the same grade.   Boys ,especially. profit from starting school a little older so I would not worry about that.  It would give them another year to mature and would assure that one does not feel left behind.   I have never seen a mother who regretted giving her child an extra year to mature but have met many who wish they had.  The children will take on your attitude about this loss.   The less you make of it the better it will be for the boys.    

  19. This family, which sticks together, is in turmoil because of a bio-dad who couldn’t apparently be bothered to be there for his child(ren). Now he sees $$$$$ and an opportunity to score. Shame on him. It would have been good for him to have been there when the boys’ mother needed help. He is the epitome of deadbeat dad-ism. Shame.

  20. i admit accidents do happen but don’t tell me that there wasn’t chatter in the backseat of that car and that the grandmother didn’t hear anything.  little boys chatter all the time, im sure one knew what the other was doing….and for another you don’t allow a jump rope in the backseat of a car if your gonna have a  window down that is not common sense, my heart does go out to the mom and the little guy but i think the grandmother was negligent and i do also believe the dissappearing dad doesn’t deserve crap out of it. 

    1. Were you there?  This is a five year old that didn’t know the danger of what he was doing. Easy for you to say that you don’t have a jump rope in the back seat of a car if a window was open is common sense. Has this happened to you before so that you know the risk? I don’t beleive the grandmother was negligent because this is a freak accident.  If you call this negligence then you could say getting your child a bicycle is negligence because you know he could fall off and get hurt. If you look at all the things children are allowed to do that you know they could get hurt doing then it could be said by your reasoning that it is negligent to allow them to do it.  Accidents happen.

    2. Are you kidding?-You could not duplicate that accident if you tried a thousand times. It was not an accident-it was a freak incident-get a clue……..

    3. madonna, you could not be more wrong. often truck back windows do not roll down, they vent out minamally. do you honestly think one child was announcing to the other “hey I am going to wrap one end of this  rope around my wrist and drop the other end out the window while my grandmother is at this red light” ? and that the grandmother somehow could not hear the conversation? ridiculous. the fact that the truck was stopped (meaning nothing was flapping around) draws into question if it was even visible to the driver while she was checking all mirrors? and I do not know how many children you have, but i have raised a couple and except for teaching them not to put a rope around each others neck, and not to stick their hands or toys out the windows, I could never imagine being fearful of an accident of this magnitude while strapped into carseats in the backseat holding a jumprope. tragic, tragic accident.

    4.  Madonna:
       Please take some time to examine your heart. This family, Father excluded, is truly a profile in courage.  You are over judging the heartbroken Grandmother who has put her life into her family. The last thing this Grandmother wanted was harm for her beautiful grandsons.  I hope that you never make a mistake and if you do I hope those around you can be more forgiving than you apparently have become.
      P.S. If you know the father, which I think you may, please walk up to him then firmly place both hands on his shoulders before proceeding to shake some sense into his head.

  21. Truly disgusting that the father is sueing their grandma!  I hope the judge has mercy on the poor mom and grandmother and the children.  The family has suffered enough!  

  22. Many of us have had the privilege to know this family and have shed tears over their pain. They all have an inner strength that will bring them through this and are surrounded by people who love them. It is sad that anyone; for whatever reason; would add any more weight on their shoulders.

  23. It’s sad hearing this poor child is frightened to look at his own hand. I hope there is a way for him to get counseling now.

  24. I believe in the strength of the human spirit and of the mind. 
    we have accomplished staggering feats, we’ve overcome insurmountable atrocities and lived on.
    I believe that this boy will turn out fine, he may need some counseling, but he’ll live on.

    when i view my personal setbacks, my injuries, i just ask myself “did i see my family get swept away by a tsunami? did i see my family get murdered before my very eyes?”  the answer is no, so i have a lot to be thankful for.
    I hope everyone keeps that in mind.

    that being said, I wish the best for the boys, i’m sure it was traumatic, but they’ll turn out to be fine people. All the parents and people have to do is believe in them.

  25. Wow, I didn’t know my childs donor had an identical twin!   I hope the judge severs his parental rights!!!

  26. Before we had “instant eerything” and media coverage of “everything” — this incident would have lived a short shelf life and people would have gotten on with theirs.  Now, it is boo-hoo time and a scarred child for life with bickering parents and more media coverage to come.  What ever happened to people with spine and strength and no need to broadcast their every move to the world?  Oh, that was the old world?  I liked it better.

    1. That’s the way things are these days, like it or not.  Family problems are often aired in public and make the news.  In this case, I think it’s the unusual nature of the accident and the horrific consequences to the little boy that make it newsworthy.  Sad for him, and I don’t think all the publicity about the family situation will make his situation easier. 

      In his mother’s defense, I’m guessing that she’s never talked to a reporter and dealt with the press before.  Reporters don’t care about their subjects as much as the story, and they will report anything they’re told.  If the mother had known that, maybe she wouldn’t have gone into so much detail.  Those parts about her little boys now wetting their beds and being afraid of the dark, all the detail about how Noah is coping with his injured arm and hand, and the father leaving her when she was 6 months pregnant, are probably things she might not want the world to know.

      1. I thought she told the tale with remarkable honesty and showed great strength…the boy is news because he has touched the hearts of thousands of people. in a world with a three second attention span and instant access to information, we move on quickly to the next ‘event’. this mother outlined part of what i am sure will be a long, long road for them all. her details give others specific items to pray about (and for that I am grateful). as for the father and when he abandoned them…well that explains the outrage over his involvement now.

        1. The story has legs because it’s a combination of sensational and human interest, written in a way that elicits sympathy for the boy and his mother and hatred for the father.  It’s interesting to contrast this BDN piece with the one published in the PPH today.  (I’m sorry I don’t know how to import the link).  I’m sure we’ll be reading more about this in the BDN.

          I wish the boy luck in his recovery.  He really is an innocent victim.

  27. What is the point of this story? This paper is starting to really sound like the National Enquirer.

  28. I hope this whole family, but especially the boys, get some counseling- it is much needed & may help with the healing process during this difficult time. As for the father…..money is what makes his world go round, enough said abouthim.

  29. i think they should sue the state for making them put the child in the back seat where you cannot watch them i thinks she probly would have had a better chance of this not happening if he was sitting in front beside her might have seen it before the jump rope was thrown out the window

  30. If i was the judge in this case, i’d quietly sit through the litigation and then award the father a huge sum of money. then as a second judgement i’d make him give it all to the boys mother for the boys well being.

  31. So sad that so many commenters feel they know everything about the father based on a few tidbits of information in a  newspaper account. If I am ever charged with a crime, I will have deep doubts about the integrity of a Maine jury. We have developed into a culture of malevolent tabloid twits.

    1. They don’t understand, and they don’t want to understand.  I hope they’re not representative of Maine jury pools.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *