FORT KENT, Maine — Those whose business it is to monitor ice conditions on Maine’s lakes, rivers and ponds are saying this week there is no safe ice in the state.

“It really is the case there is no safe ice in Maine,” Doug Rafferty, spokesman with the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife, said Wednesday. “Quite a few lakes and rivers have open water [and] it is just not advisable to be out on it right now especially if you know the water is over your head.”

On Wednesday, a search for three missing snowmobilers suspected of going through thin ice on Rangeley Lake was suspended due to extreme cold and wind conditions.

On Monday, the body of Dawn Newell of Yarmouth was recovered after she went through the ice on Rangeley Lake while snowmobiling with her son.

“Those high winds are actually opening up more water,” Rafferty said. “Tonight it should calm down.”

With wind chill advisories active over much of Maine on Wednesday, the temperatures are sufficient to freeze Maine’s water bodies, but Rafferty stressed those extreme cold spells need to last at least two weeks with little or no wind before the ice can freeze to a safe thickness.

“People have really got to be careful until then,” he said.

On Monday, officials with the Allagash Wilderness Waterway issued a release reporting hazardous ice conditions on the Allagash headwater lakes, including Big Eagle, Telos, Churchill and Chamberlain, where ice depth measured 2-5 inches with slushy conditions.

“Three inches of ice isn’t very much, and that thickness may vary from location to location,” Matthew LaRoche, waterway superintendent, said. He urged those heading out on the ice to play it safe and check the ice in the area in which they are traveling before venturing out onto it.

The AWW superintendent warned all visitors to stay away from thoroughfares and avoid tributary streams.

In northern Maine the lakes are beginning to freeze over.

“The ice is OK, but I’d be very careful,” Tenley Bennett, registered Maine guide in Eagle Lake, said Wednesday. “Conditions are slushy in lots of areas on Eagle Lake and ice thicknesses vary considerably.”

Ice fishing opened around Maine on Jan. 1 and Bennett said she has seen snowmobiles and trucks driving on Eagle Lake to ice fishing shacks.

“I wouldn’t take a truck on [the lake] just yet,” she said. “With the snowfall this winter it is difficult to judge ice conditions [and] dangerous spots might be hidden just beneath the snow.”

At Long Lake in St. Agatha, longtime ice watcher and organizer of the annual fishing derby Paul Bernier said conditions are variable on that lake as well, ranging from up to a foot on the St. Agatha end to just three inches down near Sinclair.

“Anyone who wants to go out on the lake I would suggest walking out first and drilling test holes,” Bernier said. “I do them every 50 feet and you can tell then how thick the ice is and how much [weight] it can support.”

Rafferty also advises testing ice before traveling too far on frozen bodies.

“If you are going to head out there, you had better wear something that will keep you afloat like a life jacket,” he said.

Rafferty also recommended carrying specialized ice picks which an individual could use to pull themselves back onto the ice in an emergency.

The safest course of action, outdoor enthusiasts agree, is to avoid the ice altogether for now.

“Stay off the lakes,” Kathy Mazzuchelli, director of the Caribou Parks and Recreation Department, said Wednesday. “There is still open water and running water.”

While some spots may have adequate ice, Mazzuchelli said, the danger comes from the fact several feet to the right or left of those areas the ice can be much thinner.

“People need to be really careful,” she said. “Where the trails do run on lakes or water, wait until the locals go out and mark those trails [because] they know when it is safe to ride.”

Julia Bayly is a Homestead columnist and a reporter at the Bangor Daily News.

Join the Conversation

49 Comments

  1. They can say the ice isnt safe everyday and stupid people will still go on it. Why is it called common sense when it isnt very common?

    1. Unfortunately they used a picture of a warden w/ his snowmobile on the ice…therefore a handful of people are going to assume that means the ice is fine for people and snowmobiles.

      Part of me is kidding, the other part isn’t.

  2. Everyone that goes out snowmobiling and going to cross bodies of water would be wise to invest in an Insulated Floatation Suit …..(ice fishermen also)……….. granted they are expensive, around $400, but what is your life worth ………………………

  3. I’ve seen years when people drove their trucks on eagle lake by mid-december. Other years they would have to wait until mid-january. Global warming is not something that started recently; it began thousands of years ago. I can remember back in the 40’s when it rained on Xmas day and no snow on the ground in northern maine; I was very concerned that Santa would not show up.

  4. The temps are great for ice making; they just need to be patient a bit longer and let it thicken.
    I agree with Sean.

    1. Yeah, it seems that a lot of people think that ice freezes quicker than it actually does, or don’t realize its not instantaneous and it takes a while for ice to freeze.

      Hey, what do you expect when we live in an immediate country? People do not want to wait around. People want their quick fixes.

  5. Never go on ice you have not checked this early in the season. In a couple of weeks it will be better.

  6. I’ve seen people snowmobiling across the lake. I’d hate to check out my beautiful view one day only to see someone going under knowing help won’t arrive before they drown.

  7. All of that info out there and each year someone feels, “it’ll never happen to me”. Each year a “me” goes under the ice. I can’t think of a more horrific way to go other than being a fireman trying to rescue one of these folks.

  8. They should close the lakes till they are safe. Anyone caught on the ice should be issued a ticket. I know this sounds ridiculous but if it saves lives then it should be done. A boy lost his mother on the ice the other night and it appears that three men were lost in the same area. People need to be smart and stay off the ice until they hear from state officials that the ice is safe. When you hear varying reports it does not mean that it is safe.

    1. I don’t think state officials want to get in on the business of telling us when it’s safe, that creates a whole mess of problems and liability. I remember hearing last year that a couple trucks went through the ice when there was plenty to hold them. Just hit a bad spot and in they went. People should use common sense and not push their luck.

  9. Drive to Ellsworth and look at Lucerne(Phillips) its wide open in spots and its a small lake compared to Rangeley

  10. I hope that sled is equipped with an inflatable floatation device because there appears to be open water between it and the shore.

  11. “NO SAFE ICE” Yet there he is, on the ice with a snowmobile; you can see OPEN WATER just behind him! REDUNDANT MUCH? Not too bright!

  12. 75 people so far actually have said they have been on the ice this year in the above poll. What the heck is wrong with people!!

    1. You just need to be smart about it, not every body of water is the same. I was fishing on 7 inches the first. Check it before you go and don’t push it if it’s not froze over.

  13. where was this headline a few weeks ago..But no,,, lets wait unti there are lives lost, then put a big article in the paper that the ice not safe.. U guys are rite on top of it..

  14. No reason to walk, drive, or motor across any body of water, full ice or not, anytime.
    Respect nature.

  15. “There’s ‘no safe ice’ on Maine lakes, rivers and ponds, officials say”

    Then why has the Ranger driven his snowmobile on the ice with open water visible nearby and is apparently not wearing a survival suit or even a PFD?

    1. And the photographer was out on the thin ice too, with all the heavy equipment they carry.

      1. It could just be a guy with a half-pound point-and-shoot camera, especially since the photo comes courtesy of DIFW.

  16. i like going across lakes but if the ice isn’t safe – by that I usually gauge if theres snowmobile tracks, foot traffic i don’t go

  17. Listen, what they are saying is that not all the ice is safe. It’s that way pretty much every year. Most of the ponds up my way are pretty well frozen. The idea here is to be smart. Don’t trust the ice just because there is a snowmobile track on it. When you hear of people going through the ice it’s always snowmobilers, not ice fishermen. They tend to just follow the trail in front of them. If you see someone fishing then ask them how much ice there is. They pay attention. There is plenty of safe ice available, just be smart about it.

  18. I think that the poll should ask if you would normally go on the ice. The way that I see it a lot of the people voting would not go on the ice anyhow. I have been on the ice and it is about ten inches thick with 2 inches of slush ( yesterday) and 6 inches of new snow. I don’t believe in driving on it no matter what the thickness. I’ll leave that for the more adventurist people.

  19. Touche’ Mr. Stark, my sentiments exactly. Common sense needs to take place here and not looking to blame someone else for their stupidity.

  20. No safe ice on lakes, rivers or ponds…..I bet someone is crossing an open body of water as we speak.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *