The beauty of a rivalry game is that it often exists as a separate entity.
It means something special to both teams involved. It’s especially important if both participants have endured underwhelming seasons.
That will be exactly the scenario on Saturday at 1 p.m. when UMaine football hosts arch-rival New Hampshire in the annual battle for the Brice-Cowell Musket.
UNH came into the season under first-year head coach Sean Goldrich picked fourth among 13 teams in the CAA preseason coaches poll. UNH was coming off back-to-back 8-5 seasons and FCS playoff berths.
The Wildcats have had a late resurgence, with back-to-back home wins over Rhode Island and Stony Brook, but they still come to Orono with an overall record of just 4-7 and a league mark of 3-4.
Even with a win over UMaine, it will be UNH’s fewest wins in a season since 2021, when it went 3-8. That was also the last time UMaine beat UNH. The Brice-Cowell Musket has been on display at UNH for the past four seasons and for 13 of the last 15 years. The Wildcats have owned the rivalry in recent years.
Maine enters Saturday’s contest riding a nine-game losing streak and in danger of setting the school record for losses in a season, dating back to 1892. The Black Bears are 1-6 in the conference.
They were 6-6 a year ago and were chosen seventh in this year’s CAA preseason poll.
The team’s primary problem has been its anemic offense.
There are 124 FCS schools. Of those schools, UMaine is ranked 115th or worse in five offensive categories: 123rd in points per game (12.3); 120th in red zone offense (63.6 percent conversion but just nine touchdowns in 22 chances and five field goals); 118th in fourth down conversions (31%); 117th in total yards per game (276.2 yards); and 115th in third down conversions (29.9%).
The Black Bears are 107th in rushing yards (106.1) and 102nd in passing yards (170.1).
In addition, the Black Bears have had seven kicks blocked this season, good for second-worst in the entire FCS.
UMaine fifth-year head coach Jordan Stevens replaced offensive coordinator/quarterbacks coach Mikahael Waters six games into the season with first-year assistant Sean Green, the running backs coach.
The Black Bears have averaged 15 more yards over the last four games under Green but have scored 5.5 fewer points.
Even if you don’t feel the Black Bears have been creative enough on offense with either coordinator, it still falls on the players to block, run, throw, and catch. Those have been real challenges.
During the CAA coaches’ weekly Zoom call with the media, Stevens said there are no excuses for the team’s offensive woes, but he also said he firmly believes there is talent on the offensive side of the ball.
However, he noted that many of the skill-position players are true freshmen.
“We have such a young team on offense,” said Stevens. “A true freshman tight end, four true freshmen wide receivers and another one who is a back-up running back.”
The Black Bears have also been victimized by subpar quarterback play from three inexperienced signal-callers: Caden Drezek, Eddie Buehler, and Mike McMaugh.
All have shown glimpses of promise, but Stevens will need to search the transfer portal after the season and bring in someone with experience and a good track record, much like he did with Carter Peevy from Mercer University, who lifted the program from back-to-back 2-9 seasons to 5-7 and 6-6 campaigns during his two seasons in Orono.
Stevens noted this week’s game gives the Black Bears a chance to end a dismal year on a high note.
“This is such an important game for us. It’s something we talk about all year long,” said Stevens. “We still have a program goal we can meet. It’s an opportunity to leave the jersey better than where we found it. Through all the adversity we’ve had this season, here is an opportunity to finish in a positive way.”
Something will have to give on Saturday, as UMaine is 0-4 at home and UNH is 0-5 on the road.


