Maine State Prison, the state’s largest correctional facility, located in Warren. Credit: Evan Popp / Maine Morning Star

A state commission teed up a plan Wednesday to reinstate parole in Maine, a move the incoming governor is open to after opposition from the outgoing executive.

The majority of the commission recommended bringing back the conditional early release program and making both people incarcerated in the future and those already incarcerated eligible, under specific circumstances. However, members disagreed on what those circumstances should be, punting a core question to the incoming Legislature, which will settle the specifics.

Maine was the first state to abolish parole 50 years ago and is one of 16 states that remain without it today. A proposal to reinstate the program last session failed to gain committee support, though opposition had less to do with the policy itself and more to do with how to implement such a change.

So lawmakers instead opted to examine the intersection of parole and current sentencing practices through a study commission, which held its final meeting Wednesday, lasting eight hours, to set recommendations for the next Legislature. Rep. Nina Milliken, D-Blue Hill, who introduced the parole bill last session and sat on the commission, said she plans to pursue it again when session begins in January.

Previous efforts to reinstate parole were expected to fail, because outgoing Gov. Janet Mills, a former prosecutor and state attorney general, consistently opposed such a program. The next iteration will be considered by Gov.-elect Hannah Pingree, who told Maine Morning Star she supports reinstating parole, as long as it is established in a way that weighs evidence of rehabilitation alongside risk.

Parole is not automatic but a condition granted by a parole board for someone to serve the remainder of their sentence supervised in the community, while adhering to specific rules.

“An effort to reinstate parole should focus on whether someone has demonstrated readiness to return to the community — through education, treatment, behavioral progress, and a clear plan for reentry — and ensure that decisions are made in a way that is fair, consistent, and proportionate to the individual’s circumstances,” Pingree said in a statement.

She added that, “critically, this work cannot stop at the point of release. If we expect people to succeed when they return to the community, we must ensure that the conditions for success are in place: stable housing, access to health care, pathways to employment, and strong community connections.”

Who should be eligible?

One of the key questions the commission was asked to settle was whether parole should be applied only to people convicted after a parole law is passed or also to people currently incarcerated.

Four members voted to recommend retroactive application for all crime types, with a higher evidentiary standard of rehabilitation for sexual assault and crimes against family and household members. Four members voted to recommend retroactive application with exclusions, a higher standard for retroactive application (leaving the specifics of both up to legislators) or both.

No members voted for an option to allow retroactive application for all crime types without exceptions, and one member voted to not allow retroactive application at all. One member abstained.

“I want people to think that this is not just a question of whether the incarcerated person has done good work for themselves and are in a better place,” Francine Garland Stark from the Maine Coalition to End Domestic Violence told the commission Wednesday. “I certainly hope that they are, but the harm that they have caused has not been rehabilitated. They may themselves be in a better place, but what has happened remains.”

Garland Stark and other victim advocates, who did not have a seat on the commission, offered suggestions during the final meeting, overwhelmingly urging the group not to pursue reinstating parole retroactively specifically for cases that include elevated assault, aggravated assault, attempted murder, manslaughter and murder.

While people with violent offenses are eligible for parole in other states, Maine would be an outlier if it included these types of sentences in parole retroactively.

Pointing to the Maine Department of Corrections’ mission statement to rehabilitate and the low recidivism rate touted by the department, Sen. Rachel Talbot Ross, D-Cumberland, questioned why certain cases should be excluded, if the department and a parole board were to deem the incarcerated person rehabilitated and no longer a threat to society.

Milliken added that putting such exclusions into statute doesn’t offer the nuance that exists among people who commit serious offenses. Victim advocates similarly emphasized during the meeting that victims are not a monolith.

“What the challenge of retrospect application does is it upends what people currently working on that healing process thought was going to be the parameter of their span of peace,” Garland Stark said.

Pointing to Maine’s supervised community confinement program, Christopher Laliberte, a currently incarcerated person who sits on the commission, said early release through that program is not accounted for in a judgment, because “it’s not a guarantee — it’s an opportunity.”

Supervised community confinement allows people to serve the final few months of a sentence in the community supervised by the department through probation. It is available to people in the last 30 months of their sentence, up from 18 months after a change in 2021.

“I view parole very much the same way,” Laliberte said. “It’s not taking away a judgment that a jury or a judge has given. It’s providing an opportunity for relief for someone who has done the work to prove that they have ‘rehabilitated’ themselves.”

But victims’ rights advocates said they discuss the implications of supervised community confinement with victims at length before and after sentencing, pointing out how that would not be possible if parole became retroactively eligible to people already serving sentences today.

Other commission recommendations

A key point of confusion during debate of reinstating parole last session was what would happen if conflicts arose between the administration of parole and probation violations.

The commission recommended Wednesday that the probation violation take precedence if it falls under Maine’s split sentences statute.

The commission punted on the policy question of whether a judge should be able to issue a life sentence without parole, instead voting to recommend that a future parole bill not be passed without lawmakers addressing it.

The majority of the commission also recommended parole not replace the supervised community confinement program.

During consideration of the parole bill last session, the Maine Department of Corrections argued the current system was sufficient in part because of supervised community confinement. Longtimers in Maine State Prison told Maine Morning Star that the prospects of early release through that program are too far out to have a tangible impact on motivation.

In 2026, 81 people eligible to apply for supervised community confinement did not, with 41% citing housing as a barrier and 58% reporting they weren’t interested, according to data the Department of Corrections provided the commission.

The overarching money question

Discussion of various aspects of reinstating parole made clear inadequacies in the current system, specifically when it comes to funding.

“Victim notification in our state currently is woefully underfunded and under-resourced, and fails on the regular,” said Cara Cookson, director of victim services for the Maine attorney general’s office.

Maine didn’t enact victim notification requirements until 1995, which continues to present challenges for Department of Corrections Victim Services getting contact information to notify people, Cookson added. The ability of victim witness advocates to do their work in a timely way also depends on prosecutors, and Maine has faced ongoing staffing shortages and heavy caseloads.

The commission recommended Wednesday that any parole system established include the financial and human resources necessary to have a robust victim notification system.

Maine relies heavily on the federal Victims of Crime Act to fund victim services. That federal funding has declined in recent years and the state has tried to pick up the tab.

“I think the Legislature has done a really insufficient job, and I think that’s being generous, in caring for the programs that you guys are all running,” Milliken said to victims’ services advocates during Wednesday’s meeting. “And frankly, that’s Democrats’ fault, and I’m going to say that on mic because we have been responsible for running the budget for the state for several years now and we have not done an adequate job to make sure that you guys can continue to provide the life saving services that you do for the state of Maine.”

Along with its specific recommendations regarding how to reinstate parole, the commission also agreed to include a statement in its final report recognizing that the success of the programs within a parole system would require financial investment by the Legislature.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *