As the one-year anniversary of the killing of Sunshine “Sunny” Stewart approaches, the criminal justice system continues to proceed — albeit slowly and largely behind closed doors.
“I think that the process is extremely slow and sometimes inconsiderate of the family,” said Stewart’s sister Kim Ware, “leaving us in limbo without future dates to cling onto, for months at a time. At this point we can only hope that they are all doing or have done their jobs and wait for answers. Hopefully this current wait or evaluation time will lead to bind-over and then adult trial. We want justice for Sunny but we also want a speedy and fair trial with no room for error.”
Stewart’s mother, Rebecca Wentworth, said the case has highlighted to her that the state and society have not done a good job on what to do with dangerous people.
Wentworth said her daughter’s name will be one of eight to be added to the Maine Murder Victims’ Memorial Monument in Holy Family Cemetery on Townsend Road in Augusta on Sunday, June 28. Immediately following the 1 p.m. rededication ceremony, a reception will be held at Le Club Calumet, 334 W. River Road, Augusta.
The memorial is the result of efforts of the Maine Chapter of Parents of Murdered Children.
Wentworth also said friends of Sunny want to establish a fund for women who want to get into the trades. The funds could be used for a variety of purposes to help these women, including money for tuition, licensing, or even scaffolding.
The most recent action taken in court was on May 8 when Judge Eric Walker ruled that prosecutors could obtain records related to Deven Young held by the Maine Department of Health and Human Services and Northern Light Health system. Young, 18, has been charged with the July 3, 2025, blunt force and strangulation murder of the 48-year-old Stewart, whose body was found on 100-Acre Island in Crawford Pond, Union.
“These records will provide relevant and admissible information related to the characteristics of Deven Young, his emotional attitude and pattern of living; the history of his behavior, his risk to the community, his mental health diagnosis and treatment, his ability to understand communications and his capacity to make independent decisions,” the Maine Attorney General’s Office argued in its successful request for the records.
The Attorney General’s Office stated in that motion that the state needs the records to properly prepare for a bind-over hearing to determine whether Young will be tried as a juvenile or an adult. The prosecution wants him tried as an adult.
The defense had objected to the records being provided to the prosecution.
The state will receive records compiled from May 2019 through March 31, 2025, including any medications prescribed for him.
Young turned 18 on Sept. 24, 2025, less than three months after Stewart was killed. He remains held at the Long Creek Youth Development Center in South Portland.
Judge Eric Walker ruled April 29 that the defendant is “competent to proceed based on the court’s finding that the juvenile has a rational as well as a factual understanding of the proceedings and a sufficient present ability to consult with legal counsel with a reasonable degree of rational understanding.”
If Young is tried as an adult and convicted, he would face a minimum of 25 years and up to life in prison. If tried as a juvenile, he could be held in juvenile detention no longer than age 21.
The state also noted in paperwork filed with the court that “Any records of statements made by the defendant would be admissible at hearing as admissions, and records of statements by other witnesses would likely lead to admissible evidence that would be presented through the witnesses themselves.”
The probable cause affidavit that led to Young’s arrest remains sealed. Thus, it is not known whether Young made any incriminating statements to Maine State Police or others.
Stewart grew up in the Union area and attended Medomak Valley High School. She bought and rehabbed her circa 1900 home on River Road in Tenants Harbor.
She also worked as a waitress, bartender, fisherman and carpenter. Her friends said she was a strong, self-made woman and could do anything she set her mind on.
Stewart was reported missing when she had not returned by midnight from paddle boarding on Crawford Pond. The Union Fire Department, Knox County Sheriff’s Office and Maine Warden Service searched for her. Her body was found before dawn. An autopsy by the Maine Medical Examiner’s Office determined her death was a homicide.
State police reviewed surveillance video from the campground. The footage showed Young going out in his aluminum boat before Stewart. The boat had both a motor and oars. Stewart left at 6 p.m. to go paddle boarding on Crawford Pond. Young later was seen returning to the campground in his boat.
Witnesses said that in the two weeks after Stewart’s murder, Young’s behavior did not raise suspicion. He offered to help other campers with loose pets and yard work and made wood crafts that he gave to others.
Young approached investigators and said he had information about the case. He went out on Crawford Pond in a boat with investigators and a game warden, leading them to the opposite end of 100-Acre Island from where Stewart’s body was found. When they returned to the campground, police continued interviewing him.
Investigators left the campground but returned later that night and went directly to the Youngs’ camper. Police interviewed them for two hours before arresting him on the night of July 16. Detective Erin James was the arresting officer.
Young is a resident of Frankfort. His family was at the Mic Mac Campground that is on Crawford Pond, where Stewart was also staying.
Young made his initial court appearance July 18, 2025, via Zoom from Long Creek. The hearing, held at the state court in Knox County, was open to the public at the request of the Midcoast Villager. Young entered a denial of the murder charge. He is represented by attorneys Jeremy Pratt and Caitlyn Smith. Assistant Attorneys General Lisa Bogue and Suzanne Russell are prosecuting the case.
After that hearing, the defense requested a competency hearing. State law mandates that juvenile cases be sealed for felony and murder cases if a motion for competency determination is made. The entire court file was sealed until Judge Walker’s April 29 ruling that found Young competent to stand trial.
Following Judge Walker’s April 29 ruling on Young’s competency, the Maine Forensic Service in Augusta scheduled a diagnostic evaluation of Young for June 16. Results of that evaluation will be used at the hearing to help determine whether he will be tried as an adult or juvenile. The evaluation could also be used to determine whether he can be held criminally responsible for the death if it goes to trial.
At the May 7 court hearing, the state estimated the report from the forensics evaluation would take about six weeks to complete and the defense’s expert would need about six weeks after that to review the evaluation and issue its report.
The earliest a bind-over hearing would be held is August. If the judge rules that Young be tried as an adult, the state would then present the case to a grand jury which would determine if there were reasonable grounds to charge him. The case would then be on track for a trial that could take more than a year to be held.
The defense could also appeal the ruling if the judge orders him treated as an adult. That would further delay the case reaching a trial.
A recent case in Waldo County where a 16-year-old was charged with killing a 49-year-old man in Brooks in May 2022, ended in August 2025 when the youth was sentenced to 25 years in prison.
Midcoast Villager successfully challenged in court the denial of access to police records maintained by the Waldo County Sheriff’s Office on calls that department made to Young’s home in Frankfort.
Those records showed that the parents discussed how they had sought services for Young, who spent two stints at Acadia Hospital in Bangor — a psychiatric facility — and how he did well in its day program. They said he had been on a waiting list for more than two years to get home counseling services but had not yet received those services. He was also getting therapy at Hampden Academy, according to the audio recording.
“We’ve done everything under the sun to deal with his disease,” the father said.
The teen has bipolar disorder and could go from, “fine to boiling over,” the father said. The mother also said Young could go from being the “sweetest, nicest kid you would ever meet in your life to a crazy little psycho.”
The father said Young “beat the sh*t out of her,” referring to Young’s mother, when he didn’t get his way.
Young was 5 feet, 8 inches tall and weighed 250 pounds at the time of his arrest, according to court records.
His behavior had been going on for years and years and years, the woman said. He not only had attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and oppositional disorder, but also intermittent explosive disorder. In addition to beating up his mother, leaving her with a swollen, black and blue face and other bruises, the man said Young would take a pickaxe to vehicles on the property while going on rampages.
The parents said Young would often apologize after he had his explosive behavior. Both of them expressed their concern for the teen and discussed their efforts to help him. When he failed to take his medicine, he would fly into a rage, the adults said; however, they believed he knew right from wrong.
The father said if the teen kept up his actions he would end up in jail when he turned 18.
This story appears through a media partnership with Midcoast Villager.