Outdoors
The BDN outdoors section brings readers into the woods, waters and wild places of Maine. It features stories on hunting, fishing, wildlife, conservation and recreation, told by people who live these experiences. This section emphasizes hands-on knowledge, field reports, issues, trends and the traditions that define life outside in Maine. Read more Outdoors stories here.
I’ve been asked to be the keynote speaker at a Florida birding festival this winter. I accepted. I have something to say that Florida birders want to hear, and I have something they should hear that I want to say.
The festival wants me to talk about how my summer birds up here become their winter birds down there. OK, I can do that. By far, the biggest difference is that birds sing up here, and most don’t down there. Overwintering birds are not defending breeding territories and wooing mates, so they have little reason to sing. Southern birders get to see a lot of our birds in the winter, but they don’t hear them much.
We Mainers are blessed. By the third week of May, all our local nesting birds are in full voice. You can’t shut them up. As the sun rises, the dawn chorus can be deafening. That’s a phenomenon many parts of the country never experience.
In my keynote presentation, I plan to rub it in a little. We don’t just trade people — Mainers heading south in winter to escape the cold, while Floridians venture north in summer to escape the heat — we trade bird species. I’ll suggest that Maine gets the better half of that deal.
That’s the first portion of my speech. After that, I’ll switch gears and talk about things I wish I knew when I was younger. Today I realized that I probably should share these tips with you first before telling flatlanders. Sorry. Here goes.
Make mistakes. The more often you make an identification mistake, the less often you’ll do it again. Identification skills improve more quickly when you give yourself permission to err. I wish I’d recognized that 30 years ago.


Guidebooks lie. Well, not lie exactly. They mislead. They show a depiction of the bird in perfect plumage at the perfect angle in perfect light, displaying all the key field marks, usually with arrows pointing at those key field marks. Sadly, 90% of the birds you see in the wild won’t look like their ideal guidebook pictures.
Birds reveal and conceal individual field marks in a split second. I’ve met many folks who prefer to take photos so that they can identify birds at home later. I hope they take a bunch, because one shot rarely shows all the important field marks.
Lately, I’ve been enjoying a Facebook Group called What’s this Bird? — American Birding Association (ABA). People post pictures of birds and ask for help in identifying them. I’m terrible at it. My guesses are frequently wrong. It’s been humbling, and I’ll confess I’m not often prone to humility.
From an early age, we learn to identify birds based on what we can see in a field guide picture. The guides stress color and field marks but underemphasize all the other clues that birds give us. When I was younger, I relied on my guidebook. My identification skills didn’t improve much until I put the book away and finally started noticing other important clues to a correct identification.
Overall, bird identification is easy. Most birds don’t resemble other species. But some do, and those troublesome pairs make birding seem harder than it is. Hairy and downy woodpeckers are very common birds that resemble each other. Crows and ravens do, too.
Everyone struggles to learn sparrows, since they are almost universally brown. When learning to identify troublesome birds, the shortcut is to recognize which birds are trouble. Then, learn the specific telltale clues that differentiate them. There are usually just a few key features, or species-specific behaviors and habitats, that make the identification easier.
Here’s another lesson I wish I had learned decades ago. There are many shortcuts to identifying birds that few novice birders know. For instance, often the fastest way to figure out what a bird is, is to figure out what it isn’t. There are roughly 24 breeding warblers in Maine. If you see a warbler with streaks on the breast, you can immediately eliminate half of them from consideration, since half of them have plain breasts. It’s the same with wing bars. The process of elimination is a powerful shortcut.

Another lesson I intend to convey in my keynote: treasure your time as a beginner and intermediate birder, when every positive identification feels personally thrilling. You have so many exciting discoveries ahead. Experienced birders give presentations at festivals and explain the mistakes they’ve made all their lives.


