The beginning of spring sports means new reminders for adult spectators to be gentle with young athletes. Signs posted at Little League fields outline parent do’s and don’ts. Fliers passed out on the first day of soccer describe appropriate sideline behavior. And moms everywhere whisper about the noisy dad who won’t stop yelling from the bleachers at his son on the field.

Unfortunately, an entire demographic that actually needs these “reminders” is overlooked — because they cannot read. Also, 5-year-old younger brothers usually don’t listen anyway.

You see, the number of “guidelines” is inversely proportional to the age of the athletes. What is acceptable at a 12-year-old’s Little League game is not OK at pee-wee soccer. And, ironically, my youngest son, Lindell, 5, has been to way more of the former than he has the latter. To him, sports are to be enjoyed AND won. Keeping score is not optional. And winning is the ultimate outcome.

Lindell just started playing “real” soccer last month, even though he’s had his own shin guards and cleats (to be like his older brother, Owen, 9) since February. Last year he was on an instructional team. This year, he would have no part of that; he wanted a team name, team colors and a uniform — just like his older brothers. And despite the soccer coach being the parent of a friend, Lindell wants to call her “coach.” He takes this very seriously. He is ready.

I was proud of Lindell because I, myself, have never understood the whole everyone-wins-and-gets-a-trophy mentality. Let’s be real: in sports, as in life, there are “winners” and “losers.” Hard work pays off. Talent is a rarity to be admired and treasured. No one — not even Dustin, who is pretty good at most things — can be the master of everything.

Gentle reminders and do’s and don’ts are important, but so are realistic expectations.

When Ford, now 11, was younger, he claimed to “hate soccer.”

“Let’s not blame the sport,” I told him. “Instead, be honest about your strengths and weaknesses.”

Soccer is not Ford’s talent. He’s much better at other things.

Why can’t we say that?

I’ve always chosen honesty and reality over insincere praise when it comes to sports and my children. I’m not the noisy dad yelling from the bleachers, but I’m also not the one who says, “We’re all winners,” after they’ve lost a game.

However, while I am sensitively realistic, my older boys, Ford and Owen, are just plain competitive. They keep score. They are not afraid to cheer when the other team gets an “out.” They know when they’ve lost, and they know when they’ve won. Their favorite trophies are the ones they actually earned.

So perhaps Lindell was influenced by all of us — my careful honesty and Ford and Owen’s frankness — but at his first soccer game last week, one thing suddenly became abundantly clear: if Lindell had had a Styrofoam cup of steaming coffee, he probably would have thrown it on the ground and stomped his foot when his 4- and 5-year-old teammates scored a goal … into the wrong net.

“You’re going the wrong way!” he screamed, his wispy-fine hair standing on end as it blew in the wind.

Then he sat back down on the sideline and shook his head.

I cringed and smiled apologetically at fellow parents on either side of me.

After the game, someone asked, “Did we win?”

“They don’t keep score in this league,” the referee said.

Lindell got up on his knees and said, “Of course we didn’t win. They totally beat us!”

As far as I could tell, no kid cried from his honesty.

All the way home Lindell parroted things he’s heard from his brothers: “My team’s got some work to do,” and, “We didn’t stand a chance against those guys.”

I didn’t stop him from talking this way, even if I didn’t participate in it. I didn’t tell him, “Actually, you were all winners.” Lindell wasn’t wilting or collapsing from the “defeat.” He was gathering courage and determination. Not an entirely bad lesson

A few days later, however, at his brothers’ Little League game, Lindell crossed the line and became “that dad,” only, in this case, it was “that kid.” Our baseball team was ahead by five runs. Two more runners came across home plate. Lindell got up, went to the chain-link fence and yelled, “Now, that’s what I’m talking about!”

After a quick celebration dance, one that kicked up gravel and dusty gray dirt, he went back to the fence again and said to the other team, “In your —.”

I reached over and put my hand across his mouth. He finished his sentence into the palm of my hand. I laughed anxiously and looked back at the other parents. “He can’t read,” I wanted to say. “He doesn’t understand all those do’s and don’ts.”

But instead I just smiled and said, “He’s the youngest of three boys.”

Knowing faces smiled and nodded sympathetically from the bleachers.

Maine author and columnist Sarah Smiley’s writing is syndicated weekly to publications across the country. She and her husband, Dustin, live with their three sons in Bangor. She may be reached at www.Facebook.com/Sarah.is.Smiley.

Join the Conversation

4 Comments

  1. Having now gone through a couple of years of youth sports in Bangor, I can say with confidence, that the ‘Dad’s’ yelling from the sidelines are far less cute than Lindell.  In fact, I’ve been amazed by the number of ‘Dad’s’ in this town who are trying to resolve their own short-comings, or re-live their own “glory-days” through their Little League-aged kids. One might argue that youth sports brings out the best in kids and the worst in their parents, particularly when those ‘Dad’s’ become coaches or, even worse, Youth League board members.

    Let’s not be deceived into believing that this is just a problem with men: many youth sports ‘moms’ also derive far too much of their own identities from their kids performance on the playing field. The idea that this is now being transmitted to younger siblings, as this essay implies, is more disturbing than cute. Parents should be helping kids develop perspective, not supporting the notion that one is defined by their early life achievements, or failures. Youth sports is about growing and understanding yourself, it’s not just about winning, or making your parents proud, or helping your parents feel like you might reach some potential that they were denied. Those adults who think it is have lost their way (if they ever had it).

    The real grown-ups in Bangor need to do a better job of governing youth sports and letting kids play for the fun of the game. And through modeling, they should be helping those” baseball dad’s” and “soccer-mom’s” get over themselves, or at least learn how to have fun. It’s cute when kids yell from the sidelines. It’s not so cute when adults do it.

  2. ” I, myself, have never understood the whole
    everyone-wins-and-gets-a-trophy mentality. Let’s be real: in sports, as
    in life, there are “winners” and “losers.” Hard work pays off. Talent is
    a rarity to be admired and treasured.”

    Truer words have never been spoken. Your kids will grow up knowing how life really is. You should be very proud that you have instilled in them this life lesson. Something that is now lacking in our school systems and society as well.
    Great column!

  3. I’m a youth lacrosse official in VA, with a summer home in Eastport.  I don’t do it for the game fees, which pretty much cover my gas & uniform expenses.  I do it for love of the game, and the enjoyment of teaching the correct play of the sport to youth.  I have come within a deuce of quitting, because of the “chirping” from the sidelines.  One thing I guarantee about the parents; they have NOT read the rule book, whereas I have read it, cover to cover, and more than once.  And while lacrosse IS a contact sport, at the level I officiate, rough play is discouraged.  Too many coaches should be barred because of what they promote.  The quickest way, in my mind, to ruin youth athletics is to let adults get involved.  Perhaps if no coach of an under 15 year old sport league team could be over 20 years old themselves, it might solve the problem. 

  4. These guys yell from the sidelines because they think little Johnny is gonna grow up to be David Ortiz, Michael Jordan, Zdeno Chara or Tom Brady.  But if there’s a blown call, you can’t help but get a little miffed, right? 

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *