One of the keys to success in college sports is recruiting balance.
Each class needs to have specific components as well as variety.
For hockey, each class needs goal scorers, valuable role players and efficient defensemen.
A quality goalie isn’t needed in every class but one is needed at least for every two classes.
The scoring problems for the University of Maine men’s hockey team result from the inability of coach Tim Whitehead and his staff to bring in goal scorers. Period.
They have been able to do so in the past.
Last year’s senior class, including Gustav Nyquist, who signed with the Detroit Red Wings after his junior year, had four 100-point scorers. That’s a noteworthy feat.
Goal scorers in any sport are cherished and sought by everybody.
They are the highest-paid players in professional sports because fans love goals.
Statistics show the primary reason Maine enters the Christmas break at 2-11-2 overall and 1-7-2 and in last place in Hockey East.
Maine is the lowest scoring team in the nation at 1.33 goals per game.
Maine’s 20 goals in its first 15 games are 13 fewer than its previous season-opening 15-game low. The Black Bears scored 33 goals through 15 games in the 2008-2009 season.
Their 1.33 goals-per-game average is exactly two goals fewer than they averaged last season.
And they have outshot their opponents 476-417. But their opponents have scored 22 more goals.
Maine has gone a school-record eight games without a home win (0-6-2), due primarily to the fact the Black Bears have scored only nine goals at Alfond Arena.
They have the nation’s second-worst power-play percentage at 7 percent (5-for-71). Only Harvard University has a worse percentage (6.1).
The irony?
Harvard and Maine led the nation in power-play percentage during 2011-12 at 27.3 and 26.7 percent, respectively.
Maine’s seven seniors have registered a dismal 250 points in 687 games.
That means, on average, one of them will notch a goal or an assist every 2.75 games.
The juniors register a point or an assist every 4.14 games; the sophomores every 6.78 games and the freshmen every 4.52 games.
There is simply no solution to this problem.
The players can talk about releasing their shots more quickly; driving the net with more urgency and tenacity; screening the goalie, etc.
It doesn’t matter.
They will score more often in the second half. How could they score any less?
But will they score enough to climb out of the Hockey East cellar?
Whitehead should play all eight freshmen skaters every night unless there is a good reason not to (i.e. poor practice habits, making the same mistakes over and over). Five of them have already played in at least 14 games.
So what if the freshmen make mistakes? They’ll learn from them.
If it means sitting veterans, so be it. If they aren’t producing, sit them.
And give freshman goalie Matt Morris at least one start in the next four games, all nonconference contests.
The freshmen hold the key to the future. It is a good class with potential point-producers such as current leading scorer Devin Shore, Will Merchant, Ryan Lomberg and Ben Hutton.
Sophomores Stu Higgins, Connor Leen and Jake Rutt should also continue to get significant playing time.
Sophomore defenseman Rutt has been one of the few bright spots along with the freshmen and he should continue getting a lot of minutes on the point on the power play along with impressive freshman Hutton.
Rutt and Hutton should see a lot of playing time in all situations in the second half.
Redshirt freshman Billy Norman, who had a game-high seven shots on goal in the 1-0 loss at Boston University on Dec. 8, should also start receiving quality minutes on the power-play point. Make a forward the other point man, someone who sees the ice well and has quick feet so he can create a shooting lane for himself. Leen would be a possibility.
Whitehead and his staff need to use the next four games to experiment with the lineup.
Maine’s only goal the rest of the season should be to make the Hockey East playoffs. Eight out of the 10 teams make it. Not making the league playoffs would be a disaster.
The team defense and the penalty-killing have been better of late but if the Black Bears’ scoring woes continue, it won’t matter how well they play defensively or how good the goaltending is.
There won’t be any postseason.



You know it’s bad when even Larry Mahoney writes a somewhat scathing article about Tim Whitehead and his destruction of Maine Hockey.
whitehead needs to leave to salvage maine hockey
Coach Whitehead needs to give youngsters more coaching time to salvage UMaine’s hockey future. Steve, please let this be Tim’s last year!!!
Coach Whitehead needs to resign to salvage Maine’s season……..and program.
7-42-3.
Why would any quality player come to Maine to play Hockey??
The AD should ask himself that question..
Over the years, as fans have gotten ever more frustrated with Whitehead’s leadership and the program’s downfall, the BDN message board on Larry’s articles has been the central forum for fans to vent their feelings. Many fans feel that Larry has been a Whitehead apologist/supporter by failing to acknowledge or address the fundamental issue: Whitehead’s leadership failures.
In response, a few people on here consistently maintained that Larry’s job is to “report the facts,” i.e. provide very bland reports of the games and avoid the issue of program decline.
However, what we have here is an attempt by Larry to diagnose the team’s problems and even provide a recommendation to the Coach regarding roster spots and playing time in order to improve.
Well, Larry, you have crossed the Rubicon. You can no longer attempt to stay above the fray and ignore the issue. If you don’t mind suggesting to Whitehead how to run his team why can’t you write a compelling piece outlining the program’s decline and respectfully make the case for a new coach to the AD?
In other states sportswriters do this all the time. It is self-evident to anyone that this program and its coach require the same scrutiny applied to job-performance that any working person receives daily.
you see the problem when state employees receive contracts, and the rest of us are employees at will?
employees at will receive the daily job-performance ratings daily, as you put it, while there is next to no point in giving contract employees any type of feed back. they have a contract
Yeah, Larry’s a real master of the obvious here.
Mr. Mahoney, you have come a long way. Great piece. The best thing Coach Whitehead can do at this point is resign. This season is over. Hopefully after this season, Mr. Whitehead is gone and we can turn the page on a sad chapter in UMaine hockey.
Time for a new coach!!!
Great job Timmay!!! You’ve run the program completely into the ground and you want the fans to be patient…..you’re a joke.
Replace him after Florida Classic. Any interim coach couldn’t make anything worse. Maybe let them run the team themselves.
This team has no discipline either, and that goes back to the coach. When your captain spends more time in the box than anyone else on the team, this is a problem. And its tough to score goals when you are always short handed. I have been trying to support Whitehead over the last few years, but its getting harder. He shows no emotion on the bench and never sticks up for his kids when it appears they have been wronged. That doesn’t exactly entice the players to lay it all on the line for him.
Word is they have a nice recruiting class coming in next season. Maybe its a good time to cut Tim loose and have a new coach get things started early since this season is pretty much gone anyway.
Thankfully we have Coach Mahoney here to tell us what needs to be done.
It is time for a new coach. By the end of the season, U Maine will giving away the tickets if you buy one to see a basketball game.
Firing Whitehead is not the answer.
Not in the middle of the season, but it’s the only answer at the end of the season.
yes firing him is the answer.
Certainly miss the days when a head coach would empty the bench of clipboards ,water bottles and anything else he could throw at the officials in support of his players. Mr. Whitehead is a little to passive.
All while standing on the dasher. Shawn was awesome that way. Tim’s a zombie back there…
Whitehead needs to let Corkum run this team for a while and he can just sit there with his arms crossed and chew his gum. Oh wait, he’s already chewing the gum. Silly me…