1892 — Chesley Johnson, 0-2-0
1893 — Wildes Veazie, 0-5-0
1894 — not appointed, 0-1-0
1895 — P. Folsom, 1-4-0
1896 — Jack Abbott, 1-3-2
1897 — Harry Robinson, 1-2-0
1898 — James Coombs, 0-4-0
1899 — W.B. Hopkins, 2-3-0
1900 — C. Ernest Burton, 4-4-0
1901 — J. Wells Farley, 7-1-0
1902 — E.N. Robinson, 6-2-0
1903 — J. Wells Farley, 5-3-0
1904 — King, 3-4-0
1905-08 — Frank McCoy, 10-15-4
1909 — George Schildmiller, 3-4-1
1910-11 — Edgar Wingard, 10-3-0
1912-13 — Thomas Reilly, 12-3-1
1914 — Edward B. Cochems 6-3-0
1915-16 — Thomas H. Hughlitt, 6-7-3
1917 — Thomas McCann, 1-3-0
1918 — Capt. Aldsworth, 3-1-0
1919-20 — James Baldwin, 9-4-3
1921-1940 — Fred Brice, 79-58-9
1941 — George E. Allen, 3-2-2
1942 — William Kenyon, 2-4-0
1943 — Samuel Sezak, 0-1-0
1944-45 — William Kenyon, 2-7-0
1946-48 — George E. Allen, 15-11-2
1949-50 — David Nelson, 7-5-2
1951-66 — Harold Westerman, 80-38-7
1967-75 — Walter Abbott, 27-53-0
1976-80 — Jack Bicknell, 18-35-1
1981-84 — Ron Rogerson, 19-23-1
1985-86 — Buddy Teevens, 13-9-0
1987-88 — Tim Murphy, 15-8
1989 — Tom Lichtenburg, 9-3-0
1990-92 — Kirk Ferentz, 12-21-0
1993-2015 — Jack Cosgrove, 129-135
Source: The Maine Book, University of Maine Athletics, by Stu Haskell