The 1888 racing yacht Elf has been mostly rebuilt but retains a few original pieces. It's on the older side for a wooden boat in Maine and among the oldest active racing yachts in the country. Credit: Elizabeth Walztoni / BDN

Tom Hollyday’s first time living and working on a boat through a high-stakes restoration project taught him many valuable life lessons.

After an “unconventional” childhood, he had found structure, a livelihood and a safe place to live in Maine’s schooner industry. That led him to a big undertaking restoring one boat, and the feeling of the hard work paying off is one he’ll probably chase for the rest of his life, he said.

Hollyday, now of Brooksville, is chasing that feeling with a new project: one of the country’s oldest racing yachts, the Elf, which he bought from its longtime owner for just $10.

The boat has its problems, but he’s working on plans and a search for investment to make it seaworthy. Hollyday aims to have it in the water this summer in Brooksville and eventually hopes to offer it for community sailing to pay forward what he learned working in Maine’s windjammer industry — skills that helped him adapt to adulthood and grow as a person.

“The one thing I feel I can give back is those skills,” he said. “So this becomes kind of a platform for me for not only the community to enjoy an old boat, but for me to do right by those people who’ve taught me those things, by keeping those skills alive.”

Elf was designed for racing and built around 1888, according to materials nominating it for the National Register of Historic Places, where it has been listed since 1980.

It was the start of small class racing yachts, or 30- to 35-foot yachts that people used for longer cruising trips, Hollyday said. Its original owner also used it as a kind of laboratory for splicing wire to rope, he said, a technique now commonly used in boat rigging.

An early owner sailed Elf from Massachusetts to Nova Scotia in 1893, according to an account in its National Register nomination. Offshore cruising in small yachts was “almost unknown” at the time and became a sport after that trip, he wrote.

Tom Hollyday with the Elf in the Sedgwick boatyard where the yacht is stored while he makes plans for restoration. He hopes to use it to pay forward the skills he was taught working on the water in Maine. Credit: Elizabeth Walztoni / BDN

Elf’s most recent owner, Richard Carrion, bought it in 1971 as a 19-year-old student working his way through college in Maryland, he wrote in nominating the vessel for the national register. He moved onboard and did the necessary work himself, docking near campus and bicycling to class during the semester.

In the 1980s, he started a decades-long rebuild of the vessel with a shipwright, using mostly timber from his own tree farm, finally relaunching it in 2009, according to Hollyday. Carrion kept its original deadwood keel and stem at its front.

Last year, Hollyday found Elf listed online for around $300,000 and talked him down to $10 based on problems visible in photos, bringing it from Maryland to Maine last January.

He’d been keeping his eye out for a new boat to work on after a pandemic-era project with the Hesper, which he oversaw restoration of and ran expeditions on for an employer in Portland and later as his own expedition business based in Camden.

Hollyday’s boss had originally given him the go-ahead to run a sailing program if he could find a suitable boat, but the Hesper arrived in worse shape than expected. He lived in his van next to the boat shed, pulling long days with everything he had at stake – and succeeded.

Working and living on a vessel exposes one’s weaknesses and requires facing them, he said.

“You learn about completion and like attention to detail and being focused and kind of having everything simplified for you,” he said. “…Those basic, kind of like human things, you know, the boat’s just proven to be kind of like a camp for me for that.”

He’d also never felt the accomplishment of making something objectively beautiful through the work of his hands, he said. Hesper eventually won an award for the most photogenic boat at the Eggemoggin Reach Regatta, a wooden boat race in Brooklin.

“That was kind of a feeling that I’ve always kind of wanted to chase again, because it’s really a culmination of like, oh, you can finish a task, you can complete a project, you can, you know, wake up on time and like get in and do these things, right?” Hollyday said. “Like, you’re capable of doing that, and this is the evidence…and I think that as a human being, I’m probably gonna need to chase that for the rest of my life, unfortunately.”

“For me, the shape and the size of the boat is right, the the rig is right, it’s what I like to sail and it’s what I find attractive,” Tom Hollyday said of Elf, his 1888 racing yacht. Credit: Elizabeth Walztoni / BDN

After Hesper sold, he came to Brooksville in 2025 to manage the Buck’s Harbor Marina in town. He wanted to find his next boat, but it had to be unique.

Now, Elf faces some fundamental problems tied in part to those remnants. The newer nails fastening the boat together are rusted out, and the rebuild appears to have made the Elf shorter than it looks in historical photographs, throwing off the lines.

That complicates plans for restoration, Hollyday said.

He’s had a 3D scan made and is working with Brooklin builders Hylan and Brown to create a work proposal.

Next steps would also depend on the interests and goals of an investor, and he couldn’t estimate a cost, he said.

A rebuild would require work from a larger yard, either creating an entirely new boat or opening up the existing one and lengthening it.

But Hollyday plans to do some basic work himself to get Elf in the water at Buck’s Harbor this summer where people can see it, making it a more marketable project. The marina already rents out unique wooden vessels through the “classic boat collective” program Hollyday founded, though he said Elf is a separate personal project.

Hollyday has seen many other wooden boat restoration projects falter, often because they don’t have access to marina services, but his project is unique because Buck’s Harbor resources essentially come with the boat, he said.

He thinks it’s possible to shore up Elf without having to create an entirely new boat from a mold of the existing one. It’s not clear how that might affect the National Register listing, but that’s less important than what the vessel itself means, he said.

It’s an ancient question, going back to the philosophical thought experiment of the Ship of Theseus: as each board on a vessel is replaced over time, when is it no longer the same vessel?

To Hollyday, the answer doesn’t really matter.

“It’s more about like how the boat invests in me and helps me stay on track as a human,” he said.

Elizabeth Walztoni covers news in Hancock County and writes for the homestead section. She was previously a reporter at the Lincoln County News.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *