The town of Houlton foreclosed on this property at 26 Mill St. and the owner, Albert Carmichael, sued the town for breach of contract. Credit: Kathleen Phalen Tomaselli / The County

The former owner of a downtown Houlton house that the town seized earlier this year over unpaid taxes has gone to court to challenge the town’s foreclosure of his home.

Albert Carmichael, 54, said he paid more than $2,500 in past, present and advance taxes on 26 Mill St. in late May, five months after the town foreclosed on the property. He said he believes the town is rejecting his efforts to get his house back because of a history of police calls and code enforcement issues at the property when he and his family lived there.

In a Nov. 5 emergency filing in Aroostook County Superior Court in Houlton, Carmichael sued the town for breach of contract, wrongful conversion and unjust enrichment for allegedly retaining his tax payments but stripping him of his property rights and ownership.

But the Houlton Town Council never approved any proposed agreement to return the property to Carmichael, according to the town’s records.

Carmichael had been in contact with the town attorney in June about his taxes. Believing they had reached an agreement to have the property deeded back to him, he told the Bangor Daily News he was taken aback when on Sept. 14 the town gave him 30 days to vacate the premises.

“I didn’t agree to this,” he said. “Why would I, my stuff was paid and I had no other place for me and my 16-year-old son to live.”

The town of Houlton foreclosed on this property at 26 Mill St. and the owner, Albert Carmichael, sued the town for breach of contract. Credit: Kathleen Phalen Tomaselli / The County

In public comments before the Town Council this month and in repeated correspondence with the BDN, Carmichael said he believes the town is using his prior disputes with the town and neighbors against him in not returning the property.

It started with the police chief and a neighbor, Carmichael said.

Town officials declined to comment on the seizure of Carmichael’s property, or on Carmichael’s accusation that it is connected to its history of law and code enforcement issues.

In four and a half years the property generated 93 calls to the Houlton Police Department for service, including domestic issues, family fights, overdose, theft, noise, animal complaints and littering, according to police call reports that Houlton Police Chief Tim DeLuca shared with the BDN.

Deluca declined to comment on Carmichael’s situation, but said when calls for service impact neighborhoods, the Houlton Police Department works within the law and collaborates with code enforcement to ensure lawful compliance.

Amber Jones, the new town manager, who has been on the job since Sept. 28, said Carmichael made several erroneous statements in his public comments, but declined to identify the errors. The most important aspect of the situation, she said, is “the 5 years of anguish he caused his neighbor.”

“We are working with [the neighbor] because the former residents of 26 Mill St. made no legally viable attempts to get rid of their garbage,” Jones said. “This has had a major impact on the neighbor among other disturbing and disruptive behaviors she endured.”

The neighbor, Rosa McNally, said that Jones is the first and only town manager to genuinely listen, investigate and work toward a solution.

“It is deeply angering that five years of code enforcement inaction harmed my health, safety and property value — no one should have to live in squalor because of their neighbors’ choices,” she said.

Carmichael cites three documents related to the matter in claiming he and the town worked out an agreement for him to get his house back: the letter from the town attorney and two receipts for tax payments totalling $2,501, copies of which he filed with his court complaint and provided to the BDN.

On June 4, the town’s attorney, Dan Nelson, wrote to Carmichael acknowledging tax payments for 2023, 2024 and 2025, as well as a $1,309 overpayment. In the June letter, Nelson proposed a plan to release the property back to Carmichael, who agreed to the terms in writing, according to documents filed in Aroostook County Superior Court.

In the proposed June agreement, copied to the town tax collector, Nelson detailed specific actions necessary to have the property deed reversed, including paying $550 for 2026 taxes, fixing code violations related to trash and premises, and paying a $400 release fee and $40 to record the deed, court documents show.

“I have $1,300 credit, so take it and pay taxes up to [2026] and whatever else for the other fees. Is there any way I could use what’s left to get a dumpster delivery?” Carmichael responded via email to Nelson the same day.

Still, the proposed agreement was never approved by the council.

“There is nothing that can stop the automatic foreclosure except for payment in full prior to the date of foreclosure. Tax law in Maine is very cut and dry,” Emily Mills, the town’s tax collector told the Bangor Daily News this week, without commenting on Carmichael’s specific situation. “Our administrative time has been exhausted on this topic.” 

Carmichael maintains the town is still retaining the funds he paid, but Mills said they issued a refund check in full.

In his lawsuit, Carmichael asked the court to immediately apply the funds to the liens placed by the town on the property, to convey the cleared deed back to him and issue an injunction halting any further actions or sale.

“Unfortunately, even when taxes are paid in full after the foreclosure date, the town is not required to deed the property back to the former owner,” Mills said.

On Nov. 6, Carmichael also filed an emergency motion in court to have his lawsuit court fees waived. Justice Patrick Larson denied the motion. The window is closing for Carmichael to pay the court fees. If they remain unpaid, his lawsuit will be dismissed, according to the court clerk.

Town officials said the property remains foreclosed, but there are no immediate plans to sell it.

Carmichael said he is currently living in an off-grid and unheated camper on Garrison Lane.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *