The town of Orland on Thursday chose a design for a new dam and fishway at its village center needed to hold back tides that are contaminated with mercury and improve its commercial alewife harvest.
The selected design is an early step in a project that’s expected to take many years and an estimated $14.3 million in outside funding.
The mercury contamination stems from the former Holtrachem plant in Orrington, which illegally discharged between six and 12 million tons into the Penobscot River in the late 1960s and early ’70s.
The tides have essentially trapped the mercury from washing out to sea, and appear to have begun carrying it up the Orland River, which empties into the Penobscot — held back only by a nearly century-old dam. Without it, officials expect the toxic mercury would spread through the watershed.
“Keeping that dam in place is unfortunately critical,” Select Board member Gina Bushong said Thursday after a unanimous board vote to choose the design.
Orland’s situation shows another way industrial contamination in the lower Penobscot still has significant and costly effects on the area, permanently shaping the landscape. Early court-ordered work to clean up some of the contamination further upriver in Orrington also began this summer.
The dam at Orland’s village center was built to support papermaking for Bucksport’s paper mill but never used. Orland residents voted to take ownership of it in 2010.
The tide now regularly washes over the top, longtime local Fish Warden Pete Robshaw said this summer, and mercury has been found in smaller amounts above it.
The fishway allows migratory fish — primarily alewives — to swim up the river each spring as they return from the ocean to spawn, but Robshaw previously said the current design limits their passage.
Orland is one of a few Maine towns that has kept a commercial alewife harvest for decades, though harvests have increased elsewhere in recent years as dams are removed and fish passages improved.
Alewives are used as lobster bait and also fill a key role in the food chain, feeding other fish and birds. Fishway improvements for easier passage would benefit them primarily, according to Robshaw, but elvers are also harvested in the river, and he sees occasional brown trout and bass.
He also manually opens and closes the dam gates by hand to maintain water levels, and said in June they are in bad shape.
The town completed a feasibility study this summer on options for replacing or shoring up the dam and associated fishway, using funds from one of two trusts created from a long-fought court settlement over the Holtrachem contamination.
An engineer’s inspection of the dam in April revealed no immediate issues, but found it was in fair to poor condition, particularly around the concrete gate area.
A town steering committee worked with the Select Board and the Maine Department of Marine Resources to recommend the option the Select Board decided on Thursday.
It would build a new concrete dam reinforcement abutting the downstream face of the current structure to stabilize it, add a vertical slot fishway for better passage for more species of migratory fish, and add hinged electric gates atop the dam to stop high tides from washing over it. A vertical slot fishway is a concrete channel that creates a kind of ramp.
The early cost estimate is $14.3 million, according to a summary document, with $10.1 million for the dam with the gate and $4.2 million for the fishway. That’s at the high end of the options, which started at $12.7 million.
Completing it will depend on outside funding for the small town, Bushong said. Next would come a detailed design and evaluation phase followed by extensive permitting work before construction could start.
Bushong emphasized that Thursday’s vote is just the start of a long process that will include public participation throughout.
“We’re not ready to go out and build a dam,” she said.


