The city of Ellsworth’s dispute with a local composting facility over strong odors went to a civil trial Friday after years of complaints.
The facility on Industrial Road north of downtown has operated in Ellsworth since 2017. It uses lobster waste from Greenhead Lobster’s Bucksport facility, soiled bedding from the Jackson Laboratory’s mouse-raising operation and wood chips from local arborists and wood cutters to create compost used primarily as a soil amendment.
Odors from the facility have generated a steady stream of complaints, primarily from two abutters and a nearby campground owner.
The city entered a consent agreement with Maine Organics over the odors in 2024, which allowed strong smells between 6 a.m. and 8 a.m. on weekdays. At the time, a section of its land use ordinance addressed standards for odors.
Ellsworth then enacted an odor-specific ordinance in April 2025 and served the company three notices of violation in the following months that led to Friday’s court proceeding, a bench trial where both sides made their cases to Judge Terrence Harrigan. The city was represented by attorney Tim Pease and the company by Janna Gau.
The first witness, city Code Enforcement Officer Robert Grant, said he typically gets odor complaints about the location several times a week, primarily from three separate individuals.
“Hardly a day goes by without some odor complaint,” Grant said.
The city considered the consent agreement a “problem” because it wasn’t practically enforceable, he said in response to questioning.
Gau questioned the use of his impressions of smell alone to gauge the company’s impact on neighbors, among extensive other process questions.
Grant also said he thinks town rules can be more restrictive than the state’s, while a Maine Department of Environmental Protection witness later testified the opposite. Attorneys for each side also used the state’s waste management laws in their questioning
Tim Stone, who owns a short-term rental business offering treehouses and cabins nearby, said he complained 60-plus times over the smell until giving up. He also lived on the camping property for about two years.
“Often, it’s just absolutely heinous,” he said of smells on the property he is sure come from Maine Organics.
It has at times made Stone, his wife and carpenters working on the property feel sick to their stomachs and unable to eat, he testified.
Stone described the smell as unique to Maine Organics, giving the example of it being distinct from that of a dead deer that washed ashore on his property. He said he has not lost business due to odors.
Theodore Williams, another abutter who lives and works on adjoining properties, often notices a smell multiple times per week. He recently had to leave his office because the smell was too strong for him to work and he’s working on reduced rent for his tenants there due to odor.
“It’s a sickening odor, and it rests on the property,” he said. “Everything we own smells.”
Williams has also given up on complaining to the state, he said.
Ed Stamborski, the Maine Department of Environmental Protection employee who responds to complaints there, said the department considers odors “operational” rather than a nuisance if they last an hour or two, and employees have discretion on how to apply state rules.
Stamborski said the company was generally responsive to concerns. He has come from Bangor to respond to complaints several times only to find he couldn’t smell the odor, he said, though he believes complainants do feel they’re being impacted.
None of Stamborski’s visits have resulted in a department finding that the company violated state standards, he said.
Josh Wellman, the company’s owner, said on the witness stand that he has not read the city odor ordinance and did not respond to notices of violation through the court system because he believes the 2024 consent agreement is still in effect.
He said no one from the city had communicated to him that the ordinance superseded the consent agreement or contacted him about changes to it.
Odors can come from turning the compost piles or what his attorney referred to as “acts of God” such as heavy rains or wild turkeys digging into the piles. Sometimes the piles become anaerobic and the composting process stops, creating bad smells.
Wellman has invested about $1.5 million in the site, he said, including the recent addition of six “odor cannons” spraying a balsam scent over the piles 24/7. He’s also had wood shavings added to the lobster waste before it is transported to soak up the “juice” that causes bad smells.
Pease questioned him about the use of mouse bedding soiled with urine and feces, which isn’t specified as an ingredient in appendices to the state’s composting rules. Wellman said the material is ideal for composting because it comes with sources of nitrogen and carbon, and he believes it could fit under the sawdust or wood chips categories.
City Councilor Steve O’Halloran also testified about the city’s history with the property, but Harrigan said the questions Gau asked him were irrelevant to whether Maine Organics violated city rules. Gau said she planned to argue the ordinance was unconstitutional, something Harrigan said she couldn’t do through witness testimony.
City Manager Charlie Pearce said in a courthouse interview that the city would leave it up to the judge to decide what would happen – though he mentioned financial penalties – but that Ellsworth wants the smells to stop. Odor issues unique to that property have taken up taxpayer dollars and hundreds of hours of staff time, he said.
When it sued the company in March, Ellsworth asked the court to order Wellman to pay $100 per day since the last violation notice on Sept. 10, 2025, along with the city’s attorney fees.
Closing statements from the attorneys are due in writing to Harrigan Dec. 16.
“There are many issues and moving parts to this,” the judge said at the close of Friday’s testimony.


