Outdoors
The BDN outdoors section brings readers into the woods, waters and wild places of Maine. It features stories on hunting, fishing, wildlife, conservation and recreation, told by people who live these experiences. This section emphasizes hands-on knowledge, field reports, issues, trends and the traditions that define life outside in Maine. Read more Outdoors stories here.
Two bird species that nest in Maine have just been split into four. I’m not sure whether I should be gleeful or petulant.
I envy birders who enjoy a casual relationship with Maine’s avian world, and fully appreciate a bird’s beauty without the need to identify and categorize it. For instance, purple finches and house finches resemble each other, and both visit backyard bird feeders. Casual birders don’t care which species is eating their sunflower seeds. They’re just happy to observe them.
Hardcore birders are obsessed with knowing the differences between the two species. Bird identification is a skill honed by experience. Many birders keep lists of all the birds they’ve identified in the world. Imagine how they feel when scientists shake up that world.
Willets are medium-sized shorebirds that nest primarily in southern and coastal salt marshes. Scarborough Marsh near Portland is probably the best place to look for them, but they can pop up anywhere along the Maine coast before winter sends them south.
Willets are relatively easy to identify, standing nearly a foot tall. They are a uniform gray with no obvious field marks until they spread their wings, revealing a striking W pattern in flight.
That should have been the end of it. However, there is a race of inland-nesting willets in the prairie states. In October, after long consideration, scientists declared the two different races to be two distinct species. Maine’s willet has been renamed the saltmarsh willet. The western species is now the prairie willet.
I should be happy. Without raising my binoculars, I have added another species to my life list. I’ve observed many willets in the west, so I can confirm identifying a prairie willet. According to my eBird account — my official list counter — I’ve now seen 677 species in North America.
Those same scientists just split the marsh wren into two species. Marsh wrens breed coast-to-coast. They nest in many places in Maine, wherever cattails abound. They nest in Bangor’s Penjajawoc Marsh, for instance.
For years, researchers have noticed a vocal difference between marsh wrens in the east and west. There is a narrow overlap zone in the Great Plains, where they tend not to hybridize with each other. Hence, the two races are now two distinct species — the eastern marsh wren and the western marsh wren.
Confused yet? Blame the American Ornithological Society. This group of bird-focused biologists is responsible for deciding what constitutes a species, and how to name it.

Here’s the part that can drive a birder crazy. If you’ve ever posted a marsh wren in the eastern US on your personal eBird list, eBird credits you with an eastern marsh wren. If you’ve posted a marsh wren in the western US, you get credit for a western marsh wren. If you saw or heard a marsh wren in the middle third of the country — no credit whatsoever. Your original record disappears.
I know, that’s a picky complaint that only bothers obsessive birders who keep lists. But here’s the thing. I’ve encountered marsh wrens in many places. It never mattered before, but now it does. I must head farther west to get credit, even if I’ve seen that species before. How long is this renaming thing going to go on?
A year ago, the AOS split warbling vireos into eastern and western species. They also decided to split the yellow warbler, an abundant species that breeds throughout North America, into the northern yellow warbler and the mangrove yellow warbler. The mangrove yellow warbler is a Caribbean species that barely reaches the southern US coast. Although I’ve observed yellow warblers in the Florida mangroves for about 50 years, only last March could I document the newly anointed mangrove yellow warbler for my life list — number 660 at the time.

But here’s the other thing. That warbler I watched on the edge of Florida Bay did, indeed, behave differently than the yellow warblers I’ve seen in Maine. It deserved to be its own species. For those who still believe in science, this is how evolution and natural selection work.
As birds, or any creatures, expand into new regions, they must adapt to different habitats or die. Over time, these adaptations accumulate to the point where they’re a whole new species.
The bird and the scientists aren’t the problem. I am. Listing is such a crazy compulsion. I need to get a life.
And it gets worse. Every field guide on the bookshelf just went out of date. Again.


