U.S. Rep. Jared Golden, a Democrat from Maine's 2nd District, speaks with lobstermen at a rally on the Portland waterfront on Oct. 12, 2022. Credit: Troy R. Bennett / BDN

The Bangor Daily News was the first to report this story. What you’re reading here would likely not be made public without the efforts of professional journalists asking questions, interviewing sources and obtaining documents. 

A bill to shield Maine lobstermen from new whale rules through 2035 is in doubt after Gov. Janet Mills’ administration told U.S. senators it is no longer essential.

The Maine Department of Marine Resources told a U.S. Senate panel in a letter last week obtained by the Bangor Daily News that the Northeast Lobsterman Protection Act was no longer seen as essential by the agency and a handful of groups representing lobstermen. It cited the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s pledge to examine its standards.

The move leaves the bill’s fate hanging in the final weeks of a lame-duck session. Two of its leading champions, outgoing Democratic U.S. Rep. Jared Golden and U.S. Sen. Susan Collins, who lost her reelection bid this month, will leave Congress in January. Democrats seen as less friendly to the industry could take over key committee positions.

Without the bill, the current pause expires at the end of 2028, weeks before the next president takes office. Multiple sources Monday said lawmakers in Washington were caught off guard by the department’s stance on the legislation. It had passed the House in September with the backing of the White House and was poised to move in the Senate.

Collins and independent U.S. Sen. Angus King in September asked Commerce Committee Chair Ted Cruz, R-Texas, to advance the bill through the panel, which he said he’d do just days before the election that Maine’s Republican senator lost to Democrat Troy Jackson. But the bill is not scheduled for a hearing.

Golden, who introduced the bill with U.S. Rep. Mike Lawler, R-New York, is breaking with the state and pressing the industry to keep backing it. In his own letter circulating among industry leaders and Maine’s congressional delegation and also obtained by the BDN, he wrote that the move “by DMR and others effectively kills all momentum in the Senate.”

“In response to a single whale entanglement, a new administration in control of NOAA after the 2028 election could easily reverse course and fall back into their old pattern of dismissing lobstermen’s concerns and expertise and pushing unworkable new regulations that could put you out of business,” he wrote.

NOAA is poised to craft new whale protection regulations soon. Earlier this month, it said new models suggest whale deaths and serious injuries tied to U.S. commercial fixed gear fisheries will be substantially lower than previous estimates, falling within range of the federal standard for protecting endangered North Atlantic right whales.

The shift followed the Maine Lobstermen’s Association’s 2023 victory in court, joined by DMR, over the National Marine Fisheries Service, whose “reliance on worst-case assumptions in assessing the lobster fishery’s impact” on whales jeopardized the industry, according to the association.

Lobstermen’s groups are split. Virginia Olsen of the Maine Lobstering Union Local 207 called NOAA’s new estimates “good news.” But “we are still supporting this bill,” she said, noting peer-reviewed research on the industry’s impacts to whales remains ongoing and won’t be complete until next spring. She said she’s reached out to the state, the delegation, and Republican and Democratic staffers on Cruz’s committee.

Jason Joyce, a spokesman for the New England Fishermen’s Stewardship Association, said the recent announcement from NOAA was encouraging. But he noted his group’s significant work in support of the pause and said it still supports the legislation despite being mentioned by state officials among groups no longer viewing it as crucial to protect the industry.

The department referred to its letter to the Commerce Committee, noting state officials and several groups no longer view the bill as essential “based on recent announcements outlining NOAA Fisheries’ commitment to developing durable solutions, along with improved scientific data and updated models.”

A day after NOAA’s announcement, the department brought together leadership from Maine Lobstermen’s Association, NEFSA, other groups and a stakeholder group to discuss impacts on the fishery, the agency said. The department and industry members met with congressional staff three days later and provided its statement on NOAA’s updates and the pause.

The Maine Lobstermen’s Association did not respond to requests for comment by deadline, nor did Cruz’s office and committee spokespeople, Collins’ office, Jackson’s transition team and the office of Sen. Maria Cantwell of Washington, the top Commerce Democrat, who pledged her support for the bill in Maine last month.

The Maine delegation backed Golden’s bill and generally works in tandem with industry and state officials. U.S. Rep. Chellie Pingree, a Democrat from the 1st District, said after the announcement from NOAA, her office has been in conversation with lobstermen, industry representatives and state officials “about how best to give the lobster industry the predictability it needs to plan ahead.”

King has been working for months to extend the pause, spokesperson Matthew Felling said.

“In the past week, he has heard from the state and representatives of the lobster industry about their shift in stance and continues to seek the most durable ways to put the lobster fishery in the strongest long-term position possible,” he said.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *