The BDN Editorial Board operates independently from the newsroom, and does not set policies or contribute to reporting or editing articles elsewhere in the newspaper or on bangordailynews.com.
Flying, for most of us, is a leap of faith.
We have faith that the physics of flight will keep the plane in the air. We have faith that the pilots are competent. We have faith that our fellow passengers will be mostly well behaved as we are crowded together in a metal tube hurtling across the sky miles above Earth.
We also have faith that the overworked air traffic controllers and the antiquated system they use will manage the thousands of planes in the air every day.
That faith was badly shaken last week when all flights in the U.S. were grounded Friday afternoon “out of an abundance of caution,” in the words of the Federal Aviation Administration.
Yes, the flight disruptions, delays and cancellations were inconvenient for travelers. That was acknowledged by the head of the Department of Transportation. But, what DOT Secretary Sean Duffy seems to downplay is that the unexpected suspension of all air traffic operations is more than an inconvenience. It has shaken the faith that many Americans have in our system of commercial air traffic, just days before the busiest travel days of the year.
That is why Congress must step in and do its oversight responsibility. Committees must quickly hold hearings to determine what went wrong, and more importantly, how it can be fully fixed, and when.
This isn’t so much about assigning blame, as it is about putting the U.S. on a better — and faster — track of modernizing its air traffic control system.
Friday’s shutdown was reportedly prompted by problems with the installation of new wiring at facilities in Arkansas and Texas. Problems that began at those facilities spread nationwide as communications flooded the air traffic control systems across the country.
By all accounts, America’s air traffic control system is severely outdated and the work to upgrade it has proceeded at a snail’s pace.
That is unacceptable.
It appears that the FAA has badly managed this work. This mismanagement stretches back through many presidential administrations.
While Congress has appropriated significant sums to pay for this work, the money may yet be insufficient for the huge scale of updating that is necessary.
There are also questions of who should oversee the system. While there are certainly concerns about privatizing such vital work — such as who the contractors share proprietary information with, including countries hostile to American interests — other countries, such as Canada and members of the European Union, have successfully moved to a private model.
These questions demand careful consideration. In the shorter term, Congress must get fuller answers about what prompted last Friday’s ground stop, which lasted about four hours, and what steps are being taken to avert such a situation in the future.
“The pilots and controllers faced an emergency and did their jobs. They brought thousands of passengers safely to the ground without needing to tell anyone how great their president was. The people running the system owe Americans the same seriousness,” Adam Kinzinger, a former Republican U.S. representative from Illinois and a former Air Force pilot, wrote on Facebook on Monday. “Tell us what went wrong, explain how you’re going to fix it and show us you can follow through.”
That is precisely what Congress — the nation’s oversight body — must do, despite assurances from House Speaker Mike Johnson it isn’t necessary.
Duffy and FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford have met with lawmakers and White House officials. That’s a good start, but more detailed, public oversight hearings must be held so the American people can know what happened and how both short-and long-term problems will be fixed — and how much it will cost.
These questions need to be answered as soon as possible to reassure the American people that boarding a plane is safe.


