Vehicles and flags line Main Street outside the Stonington town office on Oct. 4, 2024.

Three years after passing an ordinance to limit out-of-town ownership of short-term rentals, the island town of Stonington is seeing the results it hoped for.

As tourism increased and online bookings through sites such as Airbnb grew with it, residents worried that homes being bought as investment properties would hollow out its downtown and was hurting the housing prospects of year-round families and workers in the state’s top lobster port.

So, in March 2023, they approved by a 2-1 margin an ordinance requiring short-term rental owners to register with the town and limiting how such rentals could be operated, with a focus on regulating absentee owners.

The number of short-term rentals in Stonington owned by nonresidents listed has since dropped 14%, from 70 to 60, according to data from industry site AirDNA provided by the town. Overall, the number of short-term rentals is down from 140 in 2022 to 120 this year.

The limits are one part of a multi-pronged effort to address an acute housing shortage in the neighboring island towns of Deer Isle and Stonington that residents say seriously threatens its longevity as a year-round community. They’re trying to balance the tourism economy with the needs of its permanent workforce, a challenge particularly pronounced on the island but faced by communities across Maine.

“We are taking it seriously, and we think that all Maine towns need to take it seriously because otherwise, demographically, we are losing our workforce,” said Linda Nelson, the town’s economic and community development director. “…We are happy to be a poster child for being corrective of it.”

In 2023, Stonington had an estimated 145 short-term rentals, or 15% of its housing stock, the Bangor Daily News previously reported.

Increasing tourism was pushing it beyond the limits of its resources, particularly for drinking water, according to the town. It has had to haul in hundreds of thousands of gallons of water in recent summers, which the town’s water company has attributed to the new demand from rentals, not just drought conditions.

Especially in the densely built historic downtown, more short-term rentals created a situation like a resort without management, Nelson said: large groups and parties beyond occupancy limits and without building safety monitoring.

With vacation rentals growing from a home-based occupation of people renting out rooms into a larger commercial activity, regulations needed to catch up, according to Nelson.

“It’s government’s job to respond to markets and balance the market as best we can,” she said.

Officials hoped restricting that growth would make more of its housing stock available as year-round rentals and keep it affordable for locals. Workers pushed out by rising prices are in some cases driving an hour or more to work, and it’s a challenge for young families to find housing they can afford on the island.

The ordinance itself is similar to others enacted by coastal towns in response to increasing tourism, and out-of-towners purchasing homes as investment properties, since the pandemic and in the years just before it.

Stonington’s ordinance language frames the registry as a response to an erosion of local control over property, saying 55% of its downtown and 80% of its shoreline was owned by nonresidents.

It grandfathered all existing short-term rentals and separated them into those offered by year-round residents and nonresidents.

A person or entity can only register two short-term rental properties, followed by one more for every three local units they rent for year-round residential use. Registration fees are higher for nonresident owners and increase with every additional unit.

Short-term rental properties that aren’t also occupied by the owner cannot be within 1,000 feet of the property line of another, and the number of those units registered in a calendar year can’t be more than 1.5 times that of the year before.

The ordinance also sets safety standards, a minimum four-day stay length for units not occupied by the owner and fee penalties for not following it.

Registration doesn’t automatically transfer when a property is sold. Since 2023, 13 nonresident properties have dropped off the registry after selling, Nelson said.

Stonington is now seriously prioritizing opportunities for homeownership, according to Nelson. The island has also gained more than three dozen new year-round rentals in recent years from two privately funded projects.

In other Maine municipalities, residents have questioned whether restrictions would simply push the problem onto neighboring towns.

Deer Isle, the other town on the island, doesn’t regulate short term-rentals. The amount there has gone up by 23% in the same time period, according to AirDNA numbers.

Nelson said it’s hard to know whether that’s due to investors who would have bought in Stonington deciding to look one town over, or whether Stonington’s own numbers would have gone up without an ordinance.

“It’s really important for towns to think regionally on these things,” she said.

Deer Isle Town Manager Jim Fisher said his select board hasn’t asked for ordinances regulating them but may consider one in the future.

The town has a commercial site plan review ordinance, which hasn’t been used for short term rentals but could be a way to manage safety and environmental concerns, according to Fisher.

“Policies to discourage short-term rentals and/or seasonal housing have latent consequences, as would any policies that intervene in market systems,” he said. “…[Stonington] appear[s] to be happy with where they are headed.”

He added that Deer Isle hopes to create starter homes for year-round families, and that income needs to keep pace with markets through education, employment opportunities and the physical or online networks that allow people to get to them.

The two towns have recently hired a shared housing manager to work on numerous related plans to ease the housing crunch.

Elizabeth Walztoni covers news in Hancock County and writes for the homestead section. She was previously a reporter at the Lincoln County News.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *