The BDN Opinion section operates independently and does not set news policies or contribute to reporting or editing articles elsewhere in the newspaper or on bangordailynews.com
James C. McGuire Jr. lives in Waldoboro and is the author of the four-book “American Crossroads” series. His writing examines democracy, political division, citizenship, and the search for common ground.
Across Maine, some voters who once supported Donald Trump enthusiastically now respond very differently when asked about him. They do not defend his conduct or explain why they still support his decisions. Instead, they may say, “I don’t follow politics anymore,” “I’m sick of both parties,” or “I hate all politicians.”
Sometimes that frustration is genuine. Washington has given Americans plenty of reasons to distrust government. But sometimes these declarations sound less like political independence and more like an escape hatch — a way to avoid saying three difficult words: “I was wrong.”
These voters probably followed politics when Trump told them what they wanted to hear. They followed when he promised lower prices, better jobs, safer communities, and an end to wars. They followed when he identified enemies to blame and presented himself as the only person strong enough to rescue the country.
They wore the hats, planted the signs, repeated his accusations, and excused behavior they would never have tolerated from another president. Some dismissed every warning as fake news and treated criticism of Trump as a personal attack against themselves.
Now, as promises collide with reality and the results become harder to defend, some have suddenly stopped following politics.
That is convenient.
Saying “all politicians are crooks” spreads responsibility so widely that nobody has to accept any personally. If every officeholder is equally corrupt, then supporting Trump was no worse than supporting anyone else. Every broken promise disappears into a swamp of generalized cynicism.
But everyone is not equally responsible for every decision. We cannot cheer for one person while he is gathering power, then blame the entire political system when we dislike what he does with it. We cannot demand credit for victories while assigning every failure to Congress, the courts, the media, Democrats, immigrants, or some hidden “deep state.”
Our ballots belong to us. So does the responsibility to examine what follows from them.
That does not mean every Trump voter is a bad person. Many decent, hardworking Mainers believed his promises. Some felt ignored by Washington. Some were worried about the cost of living, their jobs, immigration, or the direction of the country. Those concerns were real, even when the proposed answers were not.
People can be deceived by slogans, frightened by propaganda, and persuaded by candidates who know how to turn genuine anxiety into personal loyalty. None of us is immune from making a poor political choice.
There is no disgrace in recognizing a mistake. In fact, changing one’s mind when confronted with evidence is a sign of judgment and character. The greater failure is recognizing the damage but refusing to acknowledge any responsibility for it.
“I was wrong” requires courage.
“I don’t follow politics anymore” requires nothing.
Walking away does not erase a vote or its consequences. Workers who lose jobs, veterans who lose services, farmers who lose markets, seniors who fear for their benefits, and families struggling to pay bills cannot simply tune politics out. They must live with what elected leaders do.
Democracy does not demand perfection from voters. It demands attention, honesty, and a willingness to reconsider when the evidence proves us wrong. Citizenship continues after Election Day.
If you supported Trump and now regret it, I urge you to say so. Say, “I believed him. I defended him. I was wrong.”
Then help repair the damage. Question the next grand promise. Reject the next convenient lie. Judge leaders by their actions instead of their party labels. Warn others about the tactics that once persuaded you.
Changing your mind is not weakness. Admitting a political mistake does not make you foolish.
It makes you an honest citizen — and honesty is something Maine and America desperately need.