AUGUSTA, Maine — A property tax task force wrapped up more than a year of work Tuesday by asking lawmakers to consider a “Taylor Swift tax” on high-value second homes, an idea it was previously told violates the Maine Constitution.
The second-home tax was a late addition. It did not appear on the draft recommendations circulated before the meeting. Members took it up at 4:57 p.m., in the closing minutes of a meeting that began at 10 a.m.
Lawmakers are responding to a pandemic-era surge in home prices, fueled partly by out-of-state buyers, that has set off tax fights in towns across the state. Now the new Legislature and Gov.-elect Hannah Pingree, a Democrat who campaigned on making out-of-state owners pay more, will have to decide if they are going to try to rewrite the constitution to do it.
The task force stopped short of recommending details on Tuesday. The nickname comes from Rhode Island’s tax on high-value homes that sit empty most of the year, a reference to the pop star’s estate in Westerly’s Watch Hill neighborhood.
Analysis shared with the task force outlined a tax on residential property that is neither the owner’s primary home nor rented out, with an exemption for property worth less than $1 million. A 0.5% tax on those homes would affect about 12,000 Maine properties and raise roughly $50 million a year, according to the Progress and Poverty Institute.
The constitution says property taxes must be “assessed equally according to the just value” of property. Changing that takes a two-thirds vote in both chambers of the Legislature before the question goes to voters, which gives House Republicans a chance to veto the idea despite resounding Democratic margins in this month’s election.
In September, a Maine Revenue Services lawyer, told the panel that the Maine Constitution rules out almost any way of taxing second homes differently from other property, including Rhode Island’s approach. He said that was as close to an unconditional answer as a lawyer could give.
Pingree has said she is prepared to pursue an amendment. She also ran on doubling the homestead exemption, which the task force endorsed Tuesday. But the group could not agree on how to pay for that.
Much of the panel’s work over the past year went into that relief program and the Property Tax Fairness Credit. Its consultants modeled ways to expand both by reallocating existing relief money rather than adding new state spending, a constraint the Legislature will also face with a $1 billion budget gap.
Two proposals for paying to double the exemption and expand the credit both failed Tuesday, and the task force moved on without one.
“It appears the task force would like to remain agnostic as to how this shall be funded,” state Sen. Nicole Grohoski, D-Ellsworth, a co-chair of the task force, said.
An earlier draft of the recommendations would have paid for the relief by cutting the state’s revenue sharing payments to towns. Without a funding source, municipal officials warned that the cost could fall on residents who don’t qualify for the breaks.
That plan would “very severely hit a very small number of remaining taxpayers” in Bangor, City Manager Carollyn Lear, a task force member, said.
“So many of our taxpayers either enjoy the credit or don’t pay any property taxes at all, and what’s left are the folks who are going to bear the burden,” Lear said.
Rep. Bob Nutting, R-Oakland, made the same point.
“I think without new money from the Legislature, in some amount, we’re not talking about property tax relief,” Nutting said. “We’re talking about property tax shifting within your community.”
The group hedged elsewhere, too. Members split on a plan for the state to pay towns for the taxes they would collect if tax-exempt property, such as land owned by the state and nonprofits, were taxable.
They did recommend letting towns levy local sales taxes, lodging taxes and other optional revenue sources to ease their reliance on property taxes. On local service fees, uptake of relief programs, audit requirements and regionalization, the group asked only for further study.
The new Legislature will be sworn in Dec. 2, and Pingree takes office in January. Grohoski joked that Tuesday’s votes summed up the group’s message to them.
“We ran out of time, so please continue the work if you want to,” she said.
Daniel O’Connor is a Report for America corps member who covers rural government as part of the partnership between the Bangor Daily News and The Maine Monitor, with additional support from BDN and Monitor readers.


